Serbia presents arguments in Kosovo debate
Source: B92, Beta, Tanjug
THE HAGUE -- The debate on the legality of Kosovo’s unilateral proclamation of independence began today before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague.
Bataković at the ICJ today (Beta/AP)
During the ten days of debates, 28 UN member-states will give their opinions on the legality of the province's ethnic Albanians' declaration, and the court will also hear from Kosovo government officials.
Foreign Minister Vuk Jeremić is attending the proceedings at the ICJ this Tuesday. The case was sent to the court last fall on Serbia's request, by the UN General Assembly.
ICJ President Hisashi Owada spoke at the beginning of the case and summed up the events leading to the process.
The unilateral declaration of independence made by Kosovo's ethnic Albanians in February 2008 represents an act of ethnically motivated secession, and is undermining the very foundations of international law, the Serbian delegation is arguing.
Serbia’s three-hour presentation was opened by the delegation chief and Belgrade's Ambassador to France Dušan Bataković.
Bataković presented Serbia’s stance on the unilateral declaration, stating that it violates the foundations of international law.
He said that the proclamation represents a challenge of the authority of the United Nations and its ability to act in the future towards achieving one of its basic principles: those of maintaining peace and security.
“It is also a challenge to international legal order based on the principles of sovereignty and territorial integrity,” Bataković continued.
He said that with the act, Priština has made Serbs into a minority group in their own country against their will.
“Serbia is convinced that the UN and international community, with the help of the advisory opinion of the judges of the International Court of Justice, will give the right answer to this challenge which strikes at the foundation of international legal order,” Bataković said, and presented the genesis of the Kosovo problem.
He said that the Kosovo crisis is not just a history of negotiations and armed conflicts, but rather a history of human suffering of the Serbian citizens, and particularly Kosovo residents of all nationalities.
“The democratic Serbia honestly laments all the tragedies and pain which it caused by those who acted in the name of Yugoslavia and Serbia during the conflict in Kosovo, and especially because of the serious violations of the human rights of the Albanian population in 1998-1999,” Bataković said.
He reminded that a number of military and police officials have been convicted by Serbian courts for the crimes committed in Kosovo.
“Serbia is convinced that the court, as it has until now, will give its opinion based exclusively on international law, independent of the balance of power between individual countries,” Bataković said.
Bataković also said that during the years of conflict, the so-called Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) made up of ethnic Albanians had committed serious crimes against Serbs, other members of the non-Albanian community, and the ethnic Albanians themselves who had been loyal to the Serbian authority in Kosovo.
He pointed out that the basic human rights of the Serbs and other non-Albanians in Kosovo were being vitally threatened and that those people were continuously pressured to move out from the region.
Bataković said that all big towns in Kosovo, with the exception of just one, had been ethnically cleansed, with no Serbs or other non-Albanians living there and reminded of the 2004 pogrom and the desecration of Serb churches and monasteries "as the only cultural monuments in Europe that are guarded by international armed forces because they are faced with the realistic threat of being demolished".
He added that the crimes which ethnic Albanian extremists had committed against Serbs and other non-Albanians in the period after June 1999 had for the most part remained unpunished, and noted that 1,300 persons were still being treated as missing, and that the same number of people had been murdered over the last ten years.
According to Bataković, the declaration represents an attempt to abolish the UN administration in Kosovo, to annul Serbia's sovereignty over its southern province and to impose independence as a unilateral solution for Kosovo.
"Serbia is confident that the court (ICJ), as it has always been the case so far, will base its advisory opinion solely on international law, regardless of the political considerations and the balance of power between certain countries," said the head of the Serbian delegation.
Even though the proclamation of Kosovo’s independence was a clear violation of UNSCR 1244 and the sovereignty of Serbia, Belgrade has decided to react in a responsible way, Bataković said.
He repeated that Serbia will not back down in its fight to defend its territorial integrity, but that the country is ready to be “flexible” in searching for a practical solution for the current situation.
Bataković said that he hopes that that the decision of the court will be such that will support the continuation of negotiations which could lead to an acceptable solution for both Belgrade and Priština.
Serbian representatives reminded the judges that the unilateral independence proclamation was made by the temporary Kosovo government and went against Resolution 1244, which guarantees the territorial integrity of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, of which Serbia is a successor.
He said that efforts of the Priština delegation to maneuver around that fact before the court were impossible, and said this attempt consisted of claims that the proclamation was not made by the temporary self-administration, but by “democratically elected representatives of the people”.
Bataković reminded that Serbia had offered ethnic Albanians broad autonomy, including membership in international organizations, but that all proposals were rejected in the status negotiations that were, according to him, doomed from the start, because of UN envoy Martti Ahtisaari's obvious bias.
Legal expert Marcelo Kohen asked what arguments could convince the court that Kosovo should be looked at as a “unique case”, which many countries that support its independence declaration have backed.
Kohen said that the UN General Assembly, Security Council or any other international institution have never before accepted the secession of the territory of a country in the way that those who support Kosovo's independence are advocating.
"The decision on the unilateral independence declaration was made by the temporary institutions that were formed in accordance with Resolution 1244. However, the assembly decision, which was signed by the Kosovo president and supported by the prime minister, was not in accordance with the Resolution, nor the constitutional framework which was in effect when the decision was made," Serbian attorney Vladimir Đerić said in his address to the court.
German international law expert Andreas Zimmermann also warned that the secession of Kosovo occurred at a time when the province was under the administration of the United Nations.
He said that there are many such missions in the world and that they are always deployed with agreement from the governments of the countries in question.
“It would be a dangerous precedent if these countries, after the Kosovo experience, concluded that the arrival of peacekeeping forces represented the first step in the secession of a crisis region which seeks independence,” he said.
The debate is set to be a historical one, since no case before the ICJ has ever had this many participants – 36 countries sent written statements and 28 will participate in the proceedings.
China will make its first appearance before the ICJ, and for the first time in 50 years, Russian and American delegations will present opposing stances on an international problem.
All five permanent members of the UN Security Council – where a resolution on Kosovo's independence failed to pass – will also be participating.
The debate was opened by the Serbian delegation, which had three hours to show that the proclamation was an ethnically motivated act of secession without precedent in international law.
Along with Serbian officials, three experts of international law – one from Argentina, one from the UK and one German – will also be speaking on behalf of Belgrade’s argument.
Even though Kosovo is not a UN member, its delegation will also be given three hours to present its arguments.
The Kosovo Albanian delegation, led by Foreign Minister Skender Hyseni and British expert Michael Wood, will not participate as a state delegation, but as the authors of a unilaterally made independence declaration.
Their argument is that Serbia, "with many years of violating the human rights of Albanians, especially in 1999", had "lost its rights to Kosovo", and that this was "confirmed by the recognition of Kosovo’s independence by some 60 countries".
Once the debate ends on December 11, the court will give its opinion on the legality of Kosovo’s independence, though a decision is not expected before the summer of 2010.
The ICJ decision will also not be binding, although it will carry undisputable legal and moral weight, says our reporter.
For this reason, the debate will see great attention being given to it by the media, with over 80 journalists from around the world expected to follow the proceedings in over the next ten days.
utorak 1.12.2009 | 18:13 | Source: Beta | Comments: (0) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The Serbian government has withdrawn the final state budget report from the parliamentary procedure.
utorak 1.12.2009 | 18:09 | Source: Danas | Comments: (0) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Justice Ministry State Secretary Slobodan Homen says changes and additions to existing laws will make sanctions for violence at sporting events more severe.
utorak 1.12.2009 | 16:55 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (19) | Send comment
THE HAGUE -- Foreign Minister Vuk Jeremić says Serbia showed wisdom, composure and strength before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on Tuesday.
utorak 1.12.2009 | 15:21 | Source: Beta | Comments: (5) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- President Boris Tadić says that he expects a positive result to the Kosovo debate before the International Court of Justice (ICJ).
utorak 1.12.2009 | 15:16 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (0) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The Ministry of Mining and Energy has made no plans to construct nuclear power plants in Serbia, according to a spokesman.
utorak 1.12.2009 | 12:36 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (0) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- European Commission (EC) Director for Western Balkans Pierre Mirel will arrive here on a two-day working visit on Thursday.
utorak 1.12.2009 | 12:17 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (1) | Send comment
BRATISLAVA -- Slovak President Ivan Gašparovič will arrive on a three-day visit to Serbia on Wednesday.
utorak 1.12.2009 | 12:13 | Source: Danas | Comments: (5) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- British Ambassador to Belgrade Stephen Wordsworth said that the visa regime the citizens of Serbia could be abolished in 2011.
utorak 1.12.2009 | 10:24 | Source: B92 | Comments: (0) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The Serbian government will hold a meeting on Tuesday afternoon to discuss the 2010 budget, government officials confirmed for B92.
ponedeljak 30.11.2009 | 18:19 | Source: FoNet | Comments: (1) | Send comment
LONDON -- President Boris Tadić said that Serbia will make a decision by the end of the year of whether it will apply for European Union candidate status.
ponedeljak 30.11.2009 | 17:41 | Source: B92, Beta, Tanjug | Comments: (72) | Send comment
BRUSSELS, BELGRADE -- The European Union (EU) has abolished visas for the citizens of Serbia traveling to the Schengen Area countries.
ponedeljak 30.11.2009 | 17:26 | Source: B92, Beta | Comments: (4) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The Serbian parliament today voted with 137 votes in favor and 24 against to adopt the new Vojvodina statute.
ponedeljak 30.11.2009 | 12:19 | Source: Beta | Comments: (24) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The governments of Russia and Serbia are in negotiations to build a nuclear power plant in Serbia, the Russian ambassador to Belgrade says.
ponedeljak 30.11.2009 | 12:17 | Source: B92 | Comments: (10) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Serbia expects that those EU member-states which do not belong to the Schengen Area will also lift their visa requirements for the Serbian citizens.
ponedeljak 30.11.2009 | 10:16 | Source: B92, Beta | Comments: (5) | Send comment
LEPOSAVIĆ -- For the first time since Serbia introduced a multiparty system in the early 1990s, the Democratic Party (DS) has won in a Kosovo municipality.
ponedeljak 30.11.2009 | 09:54 | Source: B92 | Comments: (39) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Foreign Minister Vuk Jeremić told B92 TV that he expects the ICJ to deem the Kosovo independence proclamation as a secession.
nedelja 29.11.2009 | 16:11 | Source: Beta | Comments: (5) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The EU Council of Interior and Justice Ministers will make a decision on Monday regarding the abolishment of visas for Serbia, Montenegro, and Macedonia.
nedelja 29.11.2009 | 14:33 | Source: Beta | Comments: (34) | Send comment
PRIŠTINA -- Kosovo Albanian Foreign Minister Skender Hyseni says Kosovo’s representation before the ICJ will be presenting very strong evidence to support its independence.
nedelja 29.11.2009 | 13:05 | Source: FoNet, Politika | Comments: (6) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Minister for Kosovo Goran Bogdanović said that Belgrade must do more to make sure that divisions between Kosovo Serbs does not occur.
nedelja 29.11.2009 | 10:19 | Source: Politika, Tanjug | Comments: (10) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- President Boris Tadić said that Serbia needs to focus on its obligations and convince others that the country is making progress in its EU integration.
nedelja 29.11.2009 | 09:44 | Source: FoNet | Comments: (42) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Russian ambassador to Serbia Aleksandr Konuzin said that Russia will continue to help defend the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Serbia.
subota 28.11.2009 | 17:28 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (21) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- State Secretary in the German Foreign Minister Werner Hoyer said that the climate must be created for making it easier for Belgrade to solve the Kosovo problem.
subota 28.11.2009 | 15:42 | Source: FoNet, Politika, Tanjug | Comments: (12) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The International Court of Justice denies that it has already formed its opinion on the legality of Kosovo’s independence, daily Politika reported.
subota 28.11.2009 | 15:08 | Source: Beta | Comments: (4) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Swedish ambassador to Serbia Krister Bringeus said that the Serbian people can expect to hear good news on Monday.
subota 28.11.2009 | 14:41 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (8) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- President Boris Tadić said that Serbia has two central goals currently—preserving its territorial integrity and sovereignty and joining the European Union.
subota 28.11.2009 | 13:09 | Source: B92 | Comments: (0) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Serbian President Boris Tadić will meet in Brussels on Monday with European Union senior officials, according to the president’s cabinet.
subota 28.11.2009 | 10:05 | Source: Danas | Comments: (11) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Political analyst Vladimir Goati said that he cannot imagine the opposition parties uniting and being victorious without a united pro-European platform.
subota 28.11.2009 | 09:19 | Source: Večernje novosti | Comments: (4) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Slovak Foreign Minister Miroslav Lajčak said that EU member-states need to make a political decision on Serbia’s further integration.
petak 27.11.2009 | 16:35 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (0) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- President Boris Tadić will hold meetings with European Union officials Monday in Brussels, his office said today.
petak 27.11.2009 | 16:13 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (19) | Send comment
SKOPJE -- Serbian Deputy PM Božidar Đelić said in Skopje on Friday that Belgrade recognizes Macedonia under its constitutional name.
petak 27.11.2009 | 15:12 | Source: FoNet | Comments: (4) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Foreign Minister Vuk Jeremić says he is satisfied with is week-long visit to several African countries.
petak 27.11.2009 | 13:24 | Source: Beta | Comments: (6) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The Serbian parliament is today continuing the debate on the amendments submitted to the draft law on Vojvodina's jurisdictions.
petak 27.11.2009 | 11:30 | Source: B92 | Comments: (4) | Send comment
GRAČANICA -- Several political parties and associations of Kosovo Serbs who took part in the Nov. 15 local elections have announced that they would stage protests.
petak 27.11.2009 | 11:11 | Source: Politika | Comments: (23) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Defense Minister Dragan Šutanovac stated that defense and security sector cooperation with the United States "is very important".
petak 27.11.2009 | 09:38 | Source: Danas | Comments: (8) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- President Boris Tadić has reportedly ordered state officials not to come up with public prognosis "that would irritate the Netherlands".
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 17:04 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (12) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- President of the Parliamentary Foreign Affairs Committee Dragoljub Mićunović stated that Serbia and China were on the same side in observing international law.
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 16:25 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (3) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Serbia will apply for EU candidacy after the Interim Trade Agreement (ITA) has been unfrozen, says President Boris Tadić.
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 15:26 | Source: Blic | Comments: (3) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Serbia has managed to come within reach of unfreezing of the Interim Trade Agreement, Belgrade daily Blic writes.
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 15:20 | Source: Beta | Comments: (5) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Minister for Kosovo and Metohija Goran Bogdanović has meet with the UN mission in Kosovo, UNMIK, chief Lamberto Zannier.
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 14:38 | Source: Beta, Tanjug | Comments: (15) | Send comment
STRASBOURG -- The European parliament (EP) members on Thursday in Strasbourg adopted a resolution on the EU's enlargement strategy.
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 13:44 | Source: B92, Beta | Comments: (16) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The session of the Serbian Parliament was briefly interrupted today after an opposition MP threw both her shoes at the deputy speaker.
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 11:51 | Source: Večernje novosti | Comments: (3) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The draft statute gives Vojvodina the highest level of autonomy provided by the Constitution, the provincial assembly president says.
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 09:57 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (4) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- A regional ministerial conference on climate change was opened Wednesday in Belgrade.
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 09:57 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (1) | Send comment
GENEVA -- Serbia's Interior Ministry and police (MUP) have very good cooperation with the Geneva Center for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces (DCAF).
četvrtak 26.11.2009 | 09:27 | Source: Beta, Tanjug | Comments: (20) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- President Boris Tadić met on Wednesday in Belgrade with Kuwaiti Prime Minister Sheikh Nasser al Mohammed al Ahmed al Sabah.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 20:51 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (9) | Send comment
GENEVA -- Interior Minister and First Deputy PM Ivica Dačić met in Geneva today with UNHCR High Commissioner for Refugees Antonio Guterres.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 17:07 | Source: FoNet | Comments: (8) | Send comment
BUJANOVAC -- Ethnic Albanian party PDD leader and MP Riza Halimi commented on the opening of a new Serbian Army (VS) base in the south.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 16:40 | Source: B92, Beta | Comments: (2) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Dutch Foreign Minister Maxime Verhagen will visit Belgrade on December 16, B92 has learned.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 15:26 | Source: B92, Tanjug | Comments: (6) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The Serbian parliament wrapped up initial debates of the law for transferring authorities on Tuesday and began debating the Vojvodina statute.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 15:21 | Source: B92 | Comments: (0) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Opposition New Serbia (NS) leader Velimir Ilić said that Serb Progressive Party (SNS) President Tomislav Nikolić should lead the opposition.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 14:30 | Source: Blic, Tanjug | Comments: (2) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- The new head of the Serbian Orthodox Church (SPC) is expected to be elected on January 22, reports say.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 11:31 | Source: Danas | Comments: (19) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Slovenian President Danilo Turk stated that the Dutch government was not the only one opposing the implementation the SAA between Brussels and Belgrade.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 11:28 | Source: Tanjug | Comments: (20) | Send comment
PRIŠTINA -- Serbian Minister for Kosovo Goran Bogdanović met in Priština on Tuesday with KFOR commander Lt. Gen. Markus Bentler.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 09:37 | Source: B92, Beta | Comments: (18) | Send comment
BRUSSELS -- The European Parliament’s Foreign Policy Committee is expected to adopt a resolution in support of the ratification of EU’s interim trade agreement with Serbia.
sreda 25.11.2009 | 09:29 | Source: Beta | Comments: (5) | Send comment
BELGRADE -- Coordinator of the Hague action team Rasim Ljajić says the arrest of indictee Ratko Mladić's aides was apparently a mistake.