31

Wednesday, 06.05.2015.

12:51

Serbians "will march with victors on Red Square"

President Tomislav Nikolic said on Wednesday that members of the Serbian Army (VS) will in Moscow "march in the Serbian marching step, with the victors."

Izvor: Tanjug

Serbians "will march with victors on Red Square" IMAGE SOURCE
IMAGE DESCRIPTION

31 Komentari

Sortiraj po:

Joni

pre 8 godina

(Ari Gold, 7 May 2015 19:54)
What is for you an involvement? Please?
Being occupied from an Axis member for you in not involvement?
I can't deny the Serbs war against Nazi, as much as you can not deny that since the 1939 you was supported from Union Soviet military and they armed yours partisans.
I can't deny that Hitler hate you..
He don't hate us.. He was friendly to us, so why we should fight them please? But, we CHOOSE to fight them..
I think Albania military should accepted to go to Russia, but the politics are always like this, no?
Are you kidding me?
Don't tell to me that Albania was not occupied from Germans. Germans occupied Albania and killed all the Italians they found.
Albania is in a strategic position and Germans needed our ports. To many Albanian have died for it...
Found me another country in Europe ( except. Russia ) that "broke" the Hitler order.
We was at time just around 2 millions people, to easy to exterminate for Hitler who killed around 15 million or more people in Eu.

icj1

pre 8 godina

Today 49% of the French believe that it was the USA who has won the war and only 23% remember that it was us. Who knows that in 1945 our armed forces reached 12 000 000 ? Who knows that during the war we mobilized 34 000 000 to the army ? Who cares that 38 my relatives including my Grandpa were not back ?
(rote, 7 May 2015 16:55)

Well, it's hard to blame the French for that because the facts speak for themselves. The Soviet Union might have mobilized even 100 million to the army, if you wish, but the majority of the trucks that transported them to the front were provided by the US because the Soviet Union didn't have the industrial capacity to produce that many trucks. Mobilization meant nothing if those mobilized could not be transported to the front!!!

You might spin it as you wish but ultimately it comes down to that famous saying "it's the economy, stupid"

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

If Albania was a NAZI supporter can you explain to me why Albania is part of "ALLIES COUNTRIES" against NAZI in the same time ???

- Because Albanians fought against Nazi.
- Because Albanians try to save all the Jews, and prisoners of other nationalities send to Albania. ( probably even Serbs )
(Joni, 7 May 2015 16:27)

Albania itself wasn't really involved in WWII. Germany never had a hard on for controlling Albania. It was Serbia's collective responsibility to be the primary opposition to Nazi occupation in the Balkans.

As far as the Jews finding safe haven in Albania, you are right. Because Nazi Germany never occupied or fought with Albania, many Jews were given asylum. That is commendable. But the Albanians in Kosovo-Metohija did form their own SS unit (Skenderbeg) and were some of the most loyal Nazi puppets. In return, they were allowed to control Kosovo-Metohija, and move in tons of their relatives from Albania.

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

(Isfet Benovic, 7 May 2015 13:25)

You don't know your history. Milan Nedic was imposed by the direct German military occupation of Serbia only after Belgrade was bombed, and Serbia was carved up and given off to its neighbors. Just like in the 90s really. Milan Nedic had no following, he was just one opportunist who wanted to serve as a liaison for the German occupation.

Jews also had Ghetto officers who would arrest their own people on behalf of the Nazis. Are the Jews collaborators too now? Ante Pavelic was the head of the "Independent State of Croatia", a superstate which butchered over a million Serbs, Jews and Roma.

Serbs responded to occupation by forming the majority of not one, but two anti-fascist resistance groups; Partizans & Chetniks. And it's insulting to say that Serbs were collaborators of a Nazi ideology that sought to wipe Serbs completely off the map, just because you had a few selfish people put their interests ahead of the nations. Serbs are victims of genocide.

Comm. Parrisson

pre 8 godina

"Bosniaks, croats and albanians should shut up here. They have always been friendly and allied with Nazi-Germany and Fascist-Italy.
The evil of Balkans, the evil of Europe. ...
Serbia and Serbs are and have always been a bulwark against Nazi-Fascism and their today's recrudescences."
(Gianfrancco, 7 May 2015 13:10)

And today, they are friendly and allied with Russia under Putin, a state that celebrates Stalinism and where the people see Stalin as one of the most important Russians - which is not much better than fascism and Hitler.

Remember, a similar amount (some millions) of people in the Soviet union were killed in WW2 and perished because of Stalin's mass deportations, killings, ethnic cleansing and the famine inflicted by his politics.

Teodor Muzaka 1389

pre 8 godina

Albania was a Nazi supporter?
Serb commentators here are really funny.
If Albania was a Nazi supporter, how come that they were invited to attend in parade by Putin?
We got the same invitation as Serbia.
The difference is that we said NO THANK YOU Mr Putin and that's why we are not attending the celebrations.

Joni

pre 8 godina

(BeliOraoSrbija, 7 May 2015 14:35)

If Albania was a NAZI supporter can you explain to me why Albania is part of "ALLIES COUNTRIES" against NAZI in the same time ???

- Because Albanians fought against Nazi.
- Because Albanians try to save all the Jews, and prisoners of other nationalities send to Albania. ( probably even Serbs )

rote

pre 8 godina

@rote

What does Russian schools teach about USSR part in the war from 1939-June 1941? (Dwight)

You will be surprised but they teach us the truth. This is why Russia is in a much better position over any event in the past and in the presence. We simply call spade a spade and that’s it. Once someone whom the Americans elected 4 times for presidency said that “you cannot deceive many people for a long period of time”. It’s just impossible. So we do not lie and we tell the truth even when it helps someone to go on demonizing us in everything. And it gives good results. Say every May Russians buy red flags and posters for their cars. This year most deficit are stickers with slogan ЗА РОДИНУ ! ЗА СТАЛИНА ! Those were words ( FOR MOTHERLAND ! FOR STALIN!) that our soldiers were dying with during their attacks. I too failed to find it so I took another sticker НА БЕРЛИН ! It was written on our tanks, howitzers ect. and it looks rather amusing on my German BMW-530 car. And of course I have st. George ribbon in the salon. Those are the results of what they teach us. Despite the mud and hatred the West is pouring on us we remain teflonized when it comes to our Great Victory. You may persuade anybody else that Stalin and Hitler were the same but not us.

continued

rote

pre 8 godina

Dwight


PS :

Today 49% of the French believe that it was the USA who has won the war and only 23% remember that it was us. Who knows that in 1945 our armed forces reached 12 000 000 ? Who knows that during the war we mobilized 34 000 000 to the army ? Who cares that 38 my relatives including my Grandpa were not back ? Who the hell cares that Warsaw Riot as well as the Overlord Operation were not aimed against Hitler but against the USSR ? Who cares that UK lost in WW2 only 10% of what they lost in WW1 ? Who cares that the USA supplied Hitler till late 1942 ? Who cares that the French let the Nazi enter all their colonies and sending 2 000 000 workers to Germany?

Now you try to corner me with a simpliest question about Molotov-R Pact and the Winter War of 1939. So I say that in the circumstances the Pact was very good while the war was very bad. As simple as that. The USA and the Brits backed by France and Poland made their best to send Hitler to Russia so the Pact was a diplomatic victory of the USSR that helped us gain another year before the war. Russia is one of the few states who gained no territories in accordance with the Pact. Ask Ukrainians, Poles , Romanians and the Baltic Fascists. As for Finland it was punished for joining Hitler but during WW2 they behaved good and so Stalin forgave them in a great degree. We have nothing to be ashamed for in the period you mention. If you know something please tell it to us.

the end.

Joni

pre 8 godina

(Gianfrancco, 7 May 2015 13:10)
Hmm, someone like "Gianfranco" tell to somebody to shut up. Mama mia Italiano ee??
1. Wars are not made with hands. If you are not militarily prepared and if you don't have any weapons to fight, you have no chance to resist, like it happened with Albanians.

2.I want to remember you that Serbs fought for "their existence", because Hitler decided to exterminate them. And since 1939 the Union Soviet begin to prepare militarily the Serbian resistance.

3. Hitler try to do with Albanians, the same thing that he did with Croatian, but he "failed" in his intention.
You understand?? Germany the most powerful superpower in the world at time, offered to Albanians the possibility to kick out Serbs and Greeks with their help. And Albanians decided to not accept it because we are not Serbs and Greeks we are a 'Great Albanian People".
I ask you what Serbs will have done if Germans offered to them the same thing???
Yes, i know for sure what they will do... Serbs and Turks are the same thing, they have "barbarian" instincts, they will kill all the Albanians with pleasure.

Ari Gold
Yes, there was a SS.Skanderbeg from may - november, just 6 months. And to much Albanians deserted for this it was not effective and disintegrated.
According to German sources ( not Albanian or Serbs - free to check ).
So, PLEASE, don't give to me LESSONS because we both know that if Hitler at time will give to you that "chance" you will burn us alive - with PLEASURE!!

BeliOraoSrbija

pre 8 godina

I see the usual boot licking dirty knee crowd is here trying to make Serbia guilty of everything and revise history according to the lies they have been spoon fed all their lives.

Must have all been up all night rocking the bowl and hitting the pipe, to come up with those historical fantasies they write here.

Croat's, Bosian islamites, albanians, are the open mouth axis henchmen,and will forever be just that, some things never change do they?

Dwight

pre 8 godina

@Peggy
Nationalism was involved too for sure and it was stirred up by the leaders of Croatia and Serbia in particular.
I never said Serbs were robbing Croatia, what I said was Yugoslavia lived on cheap money. When the money dried up, central government told the regions to stop spending money, the regions told central government to shove it and started to make noises about splitting
( and here is the rise of nationalism from Croatia in particular). The leaders answer to this was to try and take away power and autonomy from the regions. This just made things worse. Basically each part of Yugoslavia knew there needed to be cutbacks but not for themselves

Are the individual countries better now than they were in Yugoslavia? No, but it is not always about that. Serbia would be better off if it had just let Kosovo split peacefully but it didnt allow that and for valid reasons which had nothing to do with finances

Would they be better off if Yugoslavia stayed together? maybe, if leaders back then had made some hard choices back then instead of looking for scapegoats

Isfet Benovic

pre 8 godina

@Ari Gold.

You are well aware that Milan Nedic just like Pavelic were puppets of Germany. Both Serbs and Croats committed horrendous crimes. Please don't be so blind to the facts and say that Serbs played no part in the deportation of Jews and Roma. You call the massacre of 8,000 boys and men humane. Don't pretend to be righteous when your not. By the way the first resistance in YU during the Second World War were the Croats in Sisak. History will not be re written to destroy the lies. Give it up Ari, it's over !

Gianfrancco

pre 8 godina

Bosniaks, croats and albanians should shut up here. They have always been friendly and allied with Nazi-Germany and Fascist-Italy.
The evil of Balkans, the evil of Europe.
The built their histories on big lies, since they have not a history. And their history is just being puppets of Hitler or Mussolini. Today nothing changed, because we recently saw people as Tudjiman, Izetbegovic, Thaqi, Rama who belong to the same group of criminals who were operating during the dark decades preceding WWII or during war itself.
Serbia and Serbs are and have always been a bulwark against Nazi-Fascism and their today's recrudescences.

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

Just like they were the first balkan country to declare 'Juden Frei' in 1941. You don't deserve to march !
(Isfet Benovic, 7 May 2015 02:45)

Serbia wasn't a country during WWII. It was carved up by Germany and Belgrade + Central Serbia was directly occupied by the German military. There they committed huge atrocities against Jews and Serbs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kragujevac_massacre

Nice try, but Serbia is the only nation in Europe that had not one, but two anti-fascist movements. Serbia belongs at every Victory Day commemoration, and partners around the world are seeing that. You know who doesn't deserve to be there? The nations that produced SS Handzar, SS Skenderbeg and the "Independent" State of Croatia.

Peggy

pre 8 godina

Like a gold-digger girlfriend, why would Croatia want to stay in a union with Serbia when its wallet was empty and the EU was throwing money around.
But hey, blame "the West" if it makes you feel better
(Dwight, 6 May 2015 21:16)
============================
So it has nothing to do with nationalism being free to rise to the level of hatred after Tito died?
If it was only money as you put it then why did Croatia bring out her old Nazi symbols and salutes? Yes, those poor innocent Crotians being robbed blind by Belgrade just had to revivie the old Nazi Independent Croatia.
Do any of the former republics live any better now? I don't think so.

icj1

pre 8 godina

China also invited Serbia for WWII commemorations later this year. It's great that Serbia is recognized as a desired partner for remembering this period in history. It's only right
(Ari Gold, 6 May 2015 19:54)

Yep and that just goes to demonstrate how easy is to buy naive Serbs with some symbolic gestures. When it comes to the real stuff like http://www.b92.net/eng/news/business.php?yyyy=2015&mm=05&dd=05&nav_id=94005 romanticism is quickly set aside, except for Serbia that continues with naive thinking. If Serbia had another NIS it would have probably sold it for a fistful of RMB just to be able to get the invitation to the parade lol

Peggy

pre 8 godina

Always funny to see that people think those state break ups can be 'orchestrated', against the will of the people living there. Sure, it can be sparked, and encouraged, but when the people are satisfied with their situation, nobody would do anything.
=========================
Without political support and finance there would be no means to do it whether people wanted to or not. Give people plenty of propaganda, false hope and encouragement many will choose to go thinking that the grass is greener on the other side of the fence.
So yes, it was a plan by the west to do this and using the past spats it was very easy to incite people to do it all over again.
The west does have a lot of blood on their hands not just in the Balkans but all over the world.

Isfet Benovic

pre 8 godina

Serbians "will march with victors on Red Square"

Just like they marched on Srebrenica and massacred 8,000 innocent boys and men. Just like they were the first balkan country to declare 'Juden Frei' in 1941. You don't deserve to march !

Dwight

pre 8 godina

Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA
(Pravda, 6 May 2015 16:31)

Other ex-CIA agents will tell you other versions but I don't see you quoting them.
Yugoslavia fell apart because of money, plain and simple.
Yugoslavia lived on cheap loans from both USSR and Europe and America which Tito played off each other masterfully.
When the USSR came apart the money dried up and no one was willing to make cutbacks.
Its always easier to blame someone else so the country came apart. In some ways Serbia was not to blame. As the home of Belgrade, that is where the money was dished out from. Like a gold-digger girlfriend, why would Croatia want to stay in a union with Serbia when its wallet was empty and the EU was throwing money around.
But hey, blame "the West" if it makes you feel better

Dragoljub Djurkovic

pre 8 godina

Yes, Thank You President Nikolic, on the right path! Survival of our Slavic Eastern Orthodox people the top priority! The Human Factor, Serbian and Russian people suffered bitterly but bravely as one! Our Slavic Eastern Orthodox race in constant threat of extermination by the Satanic and evil beast Germany and the Roman Catholic Empire! Every Serbian who is alive today must know, understand and believe that their existence today would not be possible if it were not for the extreme sacrifice Russia and our Dear most beloved Russian Brothers and Sisters who fought bravely and bitterly againt Facism some seventy five years ago! If Hitler and his evil and Satanic axis of terror would of won the Second World War, no Slavic Eastern Orthodox Christian would be alive today, that is a very true fact I tell you my Dear Serbian Brothers and Sisters! Any one today who objects to Russia honoring victory over Facism and Satanism is evil and sadistic! We Christian Slavic Eastern Orthodox People worship one God, our beloved Lord Crucified and Holy in the Kingdom of Heaven! Russia and Serbia, when one bleeds the other also cries! Today the Slava of St. George, to all my Serbian Brothers and Sisters who celebrate as patron this saint God Bless You All!!!

Mick

pre 8 godina

@LK Yes a defenisive war, it was Serbs of Croatia that fought for their own right, it was Serbs from Bosnia that fought for their own rights and both did not want to be part of a Croat and Bosnian state but be a part of a Yugoslav state or Serbian state. The Serbs of Serbia did not participate after 1991.. If the remaining Yugoslav forces did participate in the war they would prevent the break up of Yugoslavia..

Mick

pre 8 godina

@comm parison,
Multi-Ethnic?
Same language same people.. is no multi ethnic, or if you consider a saxon/austrian and bavarian to be a different ethnicity then yes.
The only difference is in religion and not accepting each other.
To have a better living standard in the Ottoman empire you had to be a muslim, for Austro-Hungary you had to be Catholic. Meaning many people converted so did Serbs.
Catholics in Bosnia are of many different ethnic backgrounds (German/Hungarian/Polish/Serbian/Slovak/Czech) Same for Croatia, but most are Serbian. The region Slavonia/Vojvodina are not called Rascia(alterenative name for serbia) for nothing back in the Austrian empire. The language Serbo-croatian is pure Serbian, in the 19th C Croats took the language for themselves, their own dialect is a Slovenian dialect(kajkavian).
The people of Bih/croatia/serbia/mne are most Serbs with a different religion but because of different political things that happened in the last 100 years people created their own views and ethnicity and here we are today divided and weak..

rote

pre 8 godina

I am sure that 2 nations in Europe do not have to prove anything about the Great Victory. Those are the Serbs/Montenegrins who suffered about 300 000 combat losses and the English (220 000).Formally the Americans lost 400 000 but mostly from the Japanese. Because the USA fought them for 40 months and only 10 months against the Europeans headed by Hitler. And of course the colonial in the Far East had nothing to do with WW2.I would say that the USA simply conducted 2 wars at the time. Japan was only a formal member of the Axis. They betrayed Hitler and their PM was even coming to Moscow in 1942. Thus Serbo/Montenegrin people has suffered second big combat losses after the USSR. So (like the Brits) they don't need to explain anything or take any excuse. And if I were to decide I would arrange a joint parade in Belgrade inviting brothers in arms from Russia, Montenegro, Britain and Greece. And I would definitely send marching troops and the veterans to Moscow and Minsk Parades. S/M people deserves it more than anyone on the continent because it was almost the only fighting people outside USSR and GB. With very few exceptions like Greece ,the 20 000 Albanians, some 130 000 of the Poles all the rest sucked severely the way they could. They sucked the Germans for 3-4 years and then they sucked the Soviets & Co. But Serbs should behave as solid as the winners behave. And what do we have now ? Toma to Moscow, Vucic to Langley, Dacic to Kiev …

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

It's immensely important for Serbia to accept invitations from whoever is commemorating WWII. Serbs had to sacrifice a lot of civilian lives to stop fascism. We're talking 20 plus Croatian Nazi death camps and then all the sht that Germany itself did http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Retribution_%281941%29
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kragujevac_massacre...

China also invited Serbia for WWII commemorations later this year. It's great that Serbia is recognized as a desired partner for remembering this period in history. It's only right

Comm. Parrisson

pre 8 godina

"Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of."
(Pravda, 6 May 2015 16:31)

Always funny to see that people think those state break ups can be 'orchestrated', against the will of the people living there. Sure, it can be sparked, and encouraged, but when the people are satisfied with their situation, nobody would do anything.

So I consider it normal when multi-ethnic states forcefully created and held together by a dictator (like Tito) where some ethnic group feels dominant and is preferred (by state jobs, political influence, whatever) and other are suppressed falls apart sooner or later.

LK

pre 8 godina

"The wars of the 90's were NOT started by Serbs. They were planned & executed by the West to consolidate their gains by the downfall of the USSR. Yugoslavia was the only communist country in Europe to resist disintegration and complete take=over by western governments and the corporations that control them. For that, Yugoslavia paid a price. The Serbs were chosen as the "fall guy". Since when did Serbs EVER want to take land that was not already theirs or taken from them? Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of."

It's always some sort of conspiracy theory with you guys. There's a guy on the internet who said so, so it must be true. There's a book, so it must be true. Typical of Serbian nationalist revisionists, who are still fighting the wars of the 90's and embarrassing regular Serbs around the world.

Pravda

pre 8 godina

The wars of the 90's were NOT started by Serbs. They were planned & executed by the West to consolidate their gains by the downfall of the USSR. Yugoslavia was the only communist country in Europe to resist disintegration and complete take=over by western governments and the corporations that control them. For that, Yugoslavia paid a price. The Serbs were chosen as the "fall guy". Since when did Serbs EVER want to take land that was not already theirs or taken from them? Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of.

LK

pre 8 godina

Ha, defensive wars. So now Bosnia and Croatia were defensive wars? Ethnic cleansing was defensive? Genocide was defensive? Sarajevo is where? Vukovar is where? The Serbian government might want to forget their crimes of the 90's, but the rest of the world hasn't forgotten.

Pravda

pre 8 godina

The wars of the 90's were NOT started by Serbs. They were planned & executed by the West to consolidate their gains by the downfall of the USSR. Yugoslavia was the only communist country in Europe to resist disintegration and complete take=over by western governments and the corporations that control them. For that, Yugoslavia paid a price. The Serbs were chosen as the "fall guy". Since when did Serbs EVER want to take land that was not already theirs or taken from them? Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of.

LK

pre 8 godina

Ha, defensive wars. So now Bosnia and Croatia were defensive wars? Ethnic cleansing was defensive? Genocide was defensive? Sarajevo is where? Vukovar is where? The Serbian government might want to forget their crimes of the 90's, but the rest of the world hasn't forgotten.

Comm. Parrisson

pre 8 godina

"Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of."
(Pravda, 6 May 2015 16:31)

Always funny to see that people think those state break ups can be 'orchestrated', against the will of the people living there. Sure, it can be sparked, and encouraged, but when the people are satisfied with their situation, nobody would do anything.

So I consider it normal when multi-ethnic states forcefully created and held together by a dictator (like Tito) where some ethnic group feels dominant and is preferred (by state jobs, political influence, whatever) and other are suppressed falls apart sooner or later.

Dragoljub Djurkovic

pre 8 godina

Yes, Thank You President Nikolic, on the right path! Survival of our Slavic Eastern Orthodox people the top priority! The Human Factor, Serbian and Russian people suffered bitterly but bravely as one! Our Slavic Eastern Orthodox race in constant threat of extermination by the Satanic and evil beast Germany and the Roman Catholic Empire! Every Serbian who is alive today must know, understand and believe that their existence today would not be possible if it were not for the extreme sacrifice Russia and our Dear most beloved Russian Brothers and Sisters who fought bravely and bitterly againt Facism some seventy five years ago! If Hitler and his evil and Satanic axis of terror would of won the Second World War, no Slavic Eastern Orthodox Christian would be alive today, that is a very true fact I tell you my Dear Serbian Brothers and Sisters! Any one today who objects to Russia honoring victory over Facism and Satanism is evil and sadistic! We Christian Slavic Eastern Orthodox People worship one God, our beloved Lord Crucified and Holy in the Kingdom of Heaven! Russia and Serbia, when one bleeds the other also cries! Today the Slava of St. George, to all my Serbian Brothers and Sisters who celebrate as patron this saint God Bless You All!!!

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

It's immensely important for Serbia to accept invitations from whoever is commemorating WWII. Serbs had to sacrifice a lot of civilian lives to stop fascism. We're talking 20 plus Croatian Nazi death camps and then all the sht that Germany itself did http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Retribution_%281941%29
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kragujevac_massacre...

China also invited Serbia for WWII commemorations later this year. It's great that Serbia is recognized as a desired partner for remembering this period in history. It's only right

Mick

pre 8 godina

@LK Yes a defenisive war, it was Serbs of Croatia that fought for their own right, it was Serbs from Bosnia that fought for their own rights and both did not want to be part of a Croat and Bosnian state but be a part of a Yugoslav state or Serbian state. The Serbs of Serbia did not participate after 1991.. If the remaining Yugoslav forces did participate in the war they would prevent the break up of Yugoslavia..

Mick

pre 8 godina

@comm parison,
Multi-Ethnic?
Same language same people.. is no multi ethnic, or if you consider a saxon/austrian and bavarian to be a different ethnicity then yes.
The only difference is in religion and not accepting each other.
To have a better living standard in the Ottoman empire you had to be a muslim, for Austro-Hungary you had to be Catholic. Meaning many people converted so did Serbs.
Catholics in Bosnia are of many different ethnic backgrounds (German/Hungarian/Polish/Serbian/Slovak/Czech) Same for Croatia, but most are Serbian. The region Slavonia/Vojvodina are not called Rascia(alterenative name for serbia) for nothing back in the Austrian empire. The language Serbo-croatian is pure Serbian, in the 19th C Croats took the language for themselves, their own dialect is a Slovenian dialect(kajkavian).
The people of Bih/croatia/serbia/mne are most Serbs with a different religion but because of different political things that happened in the last 100 years people created their own views and ethnicity and here we are today divided and weak..

LK

pre 8 godina

"The wars of the 90's were NOT started by Serbs. They were planned & executed by the West to consolidate their gains by the downfall of the USSR. Yugoslavia was the only communist country in Europe to resist disintegration and complete take=over by western governments and the corporations that control them. For that, Yugoslavia paid a price. The Serbs were chosen as the "fall guy". Since when did Serbs EVER want to take land that was not already theirs or taken from them? Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of."

It's always some sort of conspiracy theory with you guys. There's a guy on the internet who said so, so it must be true. There's a book, so it must be true. Typical of Serbian nationalist revisionists, who are still fighting the wars of the 90's and embarrassing regular Serbs around the world.

Joni

pre 8 godina

(Gianfrancco, 7 May 2015 13:10)
Hmm, someone like "Gianfranco" tell to somebody to shut up. Mama mia Italiano ee??
1. Wars are not made with hands. If you are not militarily prepared and if you don't have any weapons to fight, you have no chance to resist, like it happened with Albanians.

2.I want to remember you that Serbs fought for "their existence", because Hitler decided to exterminate them. And since 1939 the Union Soviet begin to prepare militarily the Serbian resistance.

3. Hitler try to do with Albanians, the same thing that he did with Croatian, but he "failed" in his intention.
You understand?? Germany the most powerful superpower in the world at time, offered to Albanians the possibility to kick out Serbs and Greeks with their help. And Albanians decided to not accept it because we are not Serbs and Greeks we are a 'Great Albanian People".
I ask you what Serbs will have done if Germans offered to them the same thing???
Yes, i know for sure what they will do... Serbs and Turks are the same thing, they have "barbarian" instincts, they will kill all the Albanians with pleasure.

Ari Gold
Yes, there was a SS.Skanderbeg from may - november, just 6 months. And to much Albanians deserted for this it was not effective and disintegrated.
According to German sources ( not Albanian or Serbs - free to check ).
So, PLEASE, don't give to me LESSONS because we both know that if Hitler at time will give to you that "chance" you will burn us alive - with PLEASURE!!

Joni

pre 8 godina

(BeliOraoSrbija, 7 May 2015 14:35)

If Albania was a NAZI supporter can you explain to me why Albania is part of "ALLIES COUNTRIES" against NAZI in the same time ???

- Because Albanians fought against Nazi.
- Because Albanians try to save all the Jews, and prisoners of other nationalities send to Albania. ( probably even Serbs )

rote

pre 8 godina

I am sure that 2 nations in Europe do not have to prove anything about the Great Victory. Those are the Serbs/Montenegrins who suffered about 300 000 combat losses and the English (220 000).Formally the Americans lost 400 000 but mostly from the Japanese. Because the USA fought them for 40 months and only 10 months against the Europeans headed by Hitler. And of course the colonial in the Far East had nothing to do with WW2.I would say that the USA simply conducted 2 wars at the time. Japan was only a formal member of the Axis. They betrayed Hitler and their PM was even coming to Moscow in 1942. Thus Serbo/Montenegrin people has suffered second big combat losses after the USSR. So (like the Brits) they don't need to explain anything or take any excuse. And if I were to decide I would arrange a joint parade in Belgrade inviting brothers in arms from Russia, Montenegro, Britain and Greece. And I would definitely send marching troops and the veterans to Moscow and Minsk Parades. S/M people deserves it more than anyone on the continent because it was almost the only fighting people outside USSR and GB. With very few exceptions like Greece ,the 20 000 Albanians, some 130 000 of the Poles all the rest sucked severely the way they could. They sucked the Germans for 3-4 years and then they sucked the Soviets & Co. But Serbs should behave as solid as the winners behave. And what do we have now ? Toma to Moscow, Vucic to Langley, Dacic to Kiev …

Isfet Benovic

pre 8 godina

@Ari Gold.

You are well aware that Milan Nedic just like Pavelic were puppets of Germany. Both Serbs and Croats committed horrendous crimes. Please don't be so blind to the facts and say that Serbs played no part in the deportation of Jews and Roma. You call the massacre of 8,000 boys and men humane. Don't pretend to be righteous when your not. By the way the first resistance in YU during the Second World War were the Croats in Sisak. History will not be re written to destroy the lies. Give it up Ari, it's over !

Teodor Muzaka 1389

pre 8 godina

Albania was a Nazi supporter?
Serb commentators here are really funny.
If Albania was a Nazi supporter, how come that they were invited to attend in parade by Putin?
We got the same invitation as Serbia.
The difference is that we said NO THANK YOU Mr Putin and that's why we are not attending the celebrations.

Peggy

pre 8 godina

Like a gold-digger girlfriend, why would Croatia want to stay in a union with Serbia when its wallet was empty and the EU was throwing money around.
But hey, blame "the West" if it makes you feel better
(Dwight, 6 May 2015 21:16)
============================
So it has nothing to do with nationalism being free to rise to the level of hatred after Tito died?
If it was only money as you put it then why did Croatia bring out her old Nazi symbols and salutes? Yes, those poor innocent Crotians being robbed blind by Belgrade just had to revivie the old Nazi Independent Croatia.
Do any of the former republics live any better now? I don't think so.

Gianfrancco

pre 8 godina

Bosniaks, croats and albanians should shut up here. They have always been friendly and allied with Nazi-Germany and Fascist-Italy.
The evil of Balkans, the evil of Europe.
The built their histories on big lies, since they have not a history. And their history is just being puppets of Hitler or Mussolini. Today nothing changed, because we recently saw people as Tudjiman, Izetbegovic, Thaqi, Rama who belong to the same group of criminals who were operating during the dark decades preceding WWII or during war itself.
Serbia and Serbs are and have always been a bulwark against Nazi-Fascism and their today's recrudescences.

Isfet Benovic

pre 8 godina

Serbians "will march with victors on Red Square"

Just like they marched on Srebrenica and massacred 8,000 innocent boys and men. Just like they were the first balkan country to declare 'Juden Frei' in 1941. You don't deserve to march !

Dwight

pre 8 godina

@Peggy
Nationalism was involved too for sure and it was stirred up by the leaders of Croatia and Serbia in particular.
I never said Serbs were robbing Croatia, what I said was Yugoslavia lived on cheap money. When the money dried up, central government told the regions to stop spending money, the regions told central government to shove it and started to make noises about splitting
( and here is the rise of nationalism from Croatia in particular). The leaders answer to this was to try and take away power and autonomy from the regions. This just made things worse. Basically each part of Yugoslavia knew there needed to be cutbacks but not for themselves

Are the individual countries better now than they were in Yugoslavia? No, but it is not always about that. Serbia would be better off if it had just let Kosovo split peacefully but it didnt allow that and for valid reasons which had nothing to do with finances

Would they be better off if Yugoslavia stayed together? maybe, if leaders back then had made some hard choices back then instead of looking for scapegoats

Comm. Parrisson

pre 8 godina

"Bosniaks, croats and albanians should shut up here. They have always been friendly and allied with Nazi-Germany and Fascist-Italy.
The evil of Balkans, the evil of Europe. ...
Serbia and Serbs are and have always been a bulwark against Nazi-Fascism and their today's recrudescences."
(Gianfrancco, 7 May 2015 13:10)

And today, they are friendly and allied with Russia under Putin, a state that celebrates Stalinism and where the people see Stalin as one of the most important Russians - which is not much better than fascism and Hitler.

Remember, a similar amount (some millions) of people in the Soviet union were killed in WW2 and perished because of Stalin's mass deportations, killings, ethnic cleansing and the famine inflicted by his politics.

icj1

pre 8 godina

China also invited Serbia for WWII commemorations later this year. It's great that Serbia is recognized as a desired partner for remembering this period in history. It's only right
(Ari Gold, 6 May 2015 19:54)

Yep and that just goes to demonstrate how easy is to buy naive Serbs with some symbolic gestures. When it comes to the real stuff like http://www.b92.net/eng/news/business.php?yyyy=2015&mm=05&dd=05&nav_id=94005 romanticism is quickly set aside, except for Serbia that continues with naive thinking. If Serbia had another NIS it would have probably sold it for a fistful of RMB just to be able to get the invitation to the parade lol

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

If Albania was a NAZI supporter can you explain to me why Albania is part of "ALLIES COUNTRIES" against NAZI in the same time ???

- Because Albanians fought against Nazi.
- Because Albanians try to save all the Jews, and prisoners of other nationalities send to Albania. ( probably even Serbs )
(Joni, 7 May 2015 16:27)

Albania itself wasn't really involved in WWII. Germany never had a hard on for controlling Albania. It was Serbia's collective responsibility to be the primary opposition to Nazi occupation in the Balkans.

As far as the Jews finding safe haven in Albania, you are right. Because Nazi Germany never occupied or fought with Albania, many Jews were given asylum. That is commendable. But the Albanians in Kosovo-Metohija did form their own SS unit (Skenderbeg) and were some of the most loyal Nazi puppets. In return, they were allowed to control Kosovo-Metohija, and move in tons of their relatives from Albania.

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

(Isfet Benovic, 7 May 2015 13:25)

You don't know your history. Milan Nedic was imposed by the direct German military occupation of Serbia only after Belgrade was bombed, and Serbia was carved up and given off to its neighbors. Just like in the 90s really. Milan Nedic had no following, he was just one opportunist who wanted to serve as a liaison for the German occupation.

Jews also had Ghetto officers who would arrest their own people on behalf of the Nazis. Are the Jews collaborators too now? Ante Pavelic was the head of the "Independent State of Croatia", a superstate which butchered over a million Serbs, Jews and Roma.

Serbs responded to occupation by forming the majority of not one, but two anti-fascist resistance groups; Partizans & Chetniks. And it's insulting to say that Serbs were collaborators of a Nazi ideology that sought to wipe Serbs completely off the map, just because you had a few selfish people put their interests ahead of the nations. Serbs are victims of genocide.

Dwight

pre 8 godina

Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA
(Pravda, 6 May 2015 16:31)

Other ex-CIA agents will tell you other versions but I don't see you quoting them.
Yugoslavia fell apart because of money, plain and simple.
Yugoslavia lived on cheap loans from both USSR and Europe and America which Tito played off each other masterfully.
When the USSR came apart the money dried up and no one was willing to make cutbacks.
Its always easier to blame someone else so the country came apart. In some ways Serbia was not to blame. As the home of Belgrade, that is where the money was dished out from. Like a gold-digger girlfriend, why would Croatia want to stay in a union with Serbia when its wallet was empty and the EU was throwing money around.
But hey, blame "the West" if it makes you feel better

Peggy

pre 8 godina

Always funny to see that people think those state break ups can be 'orchestrated', against the will of the people living there. Sure, it can be sparked, and encouraged, but when the people are satisfied with their situation, nobody would do anything.
=========================
Without political support and finance there would be no means to do it whether people wanted to or not. Give people plenty of propaganda, false hope and encouragement many will choose to go thinking that the grass is greener on the other side of the fence.
So yes, it was a plan by the west to do this and using the past spats it was very easy to incite people to do it all over again.
The west does have a lot of blood on their hands not just in the Balkans but all over the world.

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

Just like they were the first balkan country to declare 'Juden Frei' in 1941. You don't deserve to march !
(Isfet Benovic, 7 May 2015 02:45)

Serbia wasn't a country during WWII. It was carved up by Germany and Belgrade + Central Serbia was directly occupied by the German military. There they committed huge atrocities against Jews and Serbs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kragujevac_massacre

Nice try, but Serbia is the only nation in Europe that had not one, but two anti-fascist movements. Serbia belongs at every Victory Day commemoration, and partners around the world are seeing that. You know who doesn't deserve to be there? The nations that produced SS Handzar, SS Skenderbeg and the "Independent" State of Croatia.

BeliOraoSrbija

pre 8 godina

I see the usual boot licking dirty knee crowd is here trying to make Serbia guilty of everything and revise history according to the lies they have been spoon fed all their lives.

Must have all been up all night rocking the bowl and hitting the pipe, to come up with those historical fantasies they write here.

Croat's, Bosian islamites, albanians, are the open mouth axis henchmen,and will forever be just that, some things never change do they?

rote

pre 8 godina

@rote

What does Russian schools teach about USSR part in the war from 1939-June 1941? (Dwight)

You will be surprised but they teach us the truth. This is why Russia is in a much better position over any event in the past and in the presence. We simply call spade a spade and that’s it. Once someone whom the Americans elected 4 times for presidency said that “you cannot deceive many people for a long period of time”. It’s just impossible. So we do not lie and we tell the truth even when it helps someone to go on demonizing us in everything. And it gives good results. Say every May Russians buy red flags and posters for their cars. This year most deficit are stickers with slogan ЗА РОДИНУ ! ЗА СТАЛИНА ! Those were words ( FOR MOTHERLAND ! FOR STALIN!) that our soldiers were dying with during their attacks. I too failed to find it so I took another sticker НА БЕРЛИН ! It was written on our tanks, howitzers ect. and it looks rather amusing on my German BMW-530 car. And of course I have st. George ribbon in the salon. Those are the results of what they teach us. Despite the mud and hatred the West is pouring on us we remain teflonized when it comes to our Great Victory. You may persuade anybody else that Stalin and Hitler were the same but not us.

continued

rote

pre 8 godina

Dwight


PS :

Today 49% of the French believe that it was the USA who has won the war and only 23% remember that it was us. Who knows that in 1945 our armed forces reached 12 000 000 ? Who knows that during the war we mobilized 34 000 000 to the army ? Who cares that 38 my relatives including my Grandpa were not back ? Who the hell cares that Warsaw Riot as well as the Overlord Operation were not aimed against Hitler but against the USSR ? Who cares that UK lost in WW2 only 10% of what they lost in WW1 ? Who cares that the USA supplied Hitler till late 1942 ? Who cares that the French let the Nazi enter all their colonies and sending 2 000 000 workers to Germany?

Now you try to corner me with a simpliest question about Molotov-R Pact and the Winter War of 1939. So I say that in the circumstances the Pact was very good while the war was very bad. As simple as that. The USA and the Brits backed by France and Poland made their best to send Hitler to Russia so the Pact was a diplomatic victory of the USSR that helped us gain another year before the war. Russia is one of the few states who gained no territories in accordance with the Pact. Ask Ukrainians, Poles , Romanians and the Baltic Fascists. As for Finland it was punished for joining Hitler but during WW2 they behaved good and so Stalin forgave them in a great degree. We have nothing to be ashamed for in the period you mention. If you know something please tell it to us.

the end.

Joni

pre 8 godina

(Ari Gold, 7 May 2015 19:54)
What is for you an involvement? Please?
Being occupied from an Axis member for you in not involvement?
I can't deny the Serbs war against Nazi, as much as you can not deny that since the 1939 you was supported from Union Soviet military and they armed yours partisans.
I can't deny that Hitler hate you..
He don't hate us.. He was friendly to us, so why we should fight them please? But, we CHOOSE to fight them..
I think Albania military should accepted to go to Russia, but the politics are always like this, no?
Are you kidding me?
Don't tell to me that Albania was not occupied from Germans. Germans occupied Albania and killed all the Italians they found.
Albania is in a strategic position and Germans needed our ports. To many Albanian have died for it...
Found me another country in Europe ( except. Russia ) that "broke" the Hitler order.
We was at time just around 2 millions people, to easy to exterminate for Hitler who killed around 15 million or more people in Eu.

icj1

pre 8 godina

Today 49% of the French believe that it was the USA who has won the war and only 23% remember that it was us. Who knows that in 1945 our armed forces reached 12 000 000 ? Who knows that during the war we mobilized 34 000 000 to the army ? Who cares that 38 my relatives including my Grandpa were not back ?
(rote, 7 May 2015 16:55)

Well, it's hard to blame the French for that because the facts speak for themselves. The Soviet Union might have mobilized even 100 million to the army, if you wish, but the majority of the trucks that transported them to the front were provided by the US because the Soviet Union didn't have the industrial capacity to produce that many trucks. Mobilization meant nothing if those mobilized could not be transported to the front!!!

You might spin it as you wish but ultimately it comes down to that famous saying "it's the economy, stupid"

LK

pre 8 godina

Ha, defensive wars. So now Bosnia and Croatia were defensive wars? Ethnic cleansing was defensive? Genocide was defensive? Sarajevo is where? Vukovar is where? The Serbian government might want to forget their crimes of the 90's, but the rest of the world hasn't forgotten.

Pravda

pre 8 godina

The wars of the 90's were NOT started by Serbs. They were planned & executed by the West to consolidate their gains by the downfall of the USSR. Yugoslavia was the only communist country in Europe to resist disintegration and complete take=over by western governments and the corporations that control them. For that, Yugoslavia paid a price. The Serbs were chosen as the "fall guy". Since when did Serbs EVER want to take land that was not already theirs or taken from them? Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of.

Isfet Benovic

pre 8 godina

Serbians "will march with victors on Red Square"

Just like they marched on Srebrenica and massacred 8,000 innocent boys and men. Just like they were the first balkan country to declare 'Juden Frei' in 1941. You don't deserve to march !

LK

pre 8 godina

"The wars of the 90's were NOT started by Serbs. They were planned & executed by the West to consolidate their gains by the downfall of the USSR. Yugoslavia was the only communist country in Europe to resist disintegration and complete take=over by western governments and the corporations that control them. For that, Yugoslavia paid a price. The Serbs were chosen as the "fall guy". Since when did Serbs EVER want to take land that was not already theirs or taken from them? Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of."

It's always some sort of conspiracy theory with you guys. There's a guy on the internet who said so, so it must be true. There's a book, so it must be true. Typical of Serbian nationalist revisionists, who are still fighting the wars of the 90's and embarrassing regular Serbs around the world.

Dragoljub Djurkovic

pre 8 godina

Yes, Thank You President Nikolic, on the right path! Survival of our Slavic Eastern Orthodox people the top priority! The Human Factor, Serbian and Russian people suffered bitterly but bravely as one! Our Slavic Eastern Orthodox race in constant threat of extermination by the Satanic and evil beast Germany and the Roman Catholic Empire! Every Serbian who is alive today must know, understand and believe that their existence today would not be possible if it were not for the extreme sacrifice Russia and our Dear most beloved Russian Brothers and Sisters who fought bravely and bitterly againt Facism some seventy five years ago! If Hitler and his evil and Satanic axis of terror would of won the Second World War, no Slavic Eastern Orthodox Christian would be alive today, that is a very true fact I tell you my Dear Serbian Brothers and Sisters! Any one today who objects to Russia honoring victory over Facism and Satanism is evil and sadistic! We Christian Slavic Eastern Orthodox People worship one God, our beloved Lord Crucified and Holy in the Kingdom of Heaven! Russia and Serbia, when one bleeds the other also cries! Today the Slava of St. George, to all my Serbian Brothers and Sisters who celebrate as patron this saint God Bless You All!!!

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

(Isfet Benovic, 7 May 2015 13:25)

You don't know your history. Milan Nedic was imposed by the direct German military occupation of Serbia only after Belgrade was bombed, and Serbia was carved up and given off to its neighbors. Just like in the 90s really. Milan Nedic had no following, he was just one opportunist who wanted to serve as a liaison for the German occupation.

Jews also had Ghetto officers who would arrest their own people on behalf of the Nazis. Are the Jews collaborators too now? Ante Pavelic was the head of the "Independent State of Croatia", a superstate which butchered over a million Serbs, Jews and Roma.

Serbs responded to occupation by forming the majority of not one, but two anti-fascist resistance groups; Partizans & Chetniks. And it's insulting to say that Serbs were collaborators of a Nazi ideology that sought to wipe Serbs completely off the map, just because you had a few selfish people put their interests ahead of the nations. Serbs are victims of genocide.

Comm. Parrisson

pre 8 godina

"Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA. Before it was considered a theory, now its known to be a fact. If you still can't see that, I feel sorry for your level of intelligence, or lack there of."
(Pravda, 6 May 2015 16:31)

Always funny to see that people think those state break ups can be 'orchestrated', against the will of the people living there. Sure, it can be sparked, and encouraged, but when the people are satisfied with their situation, nobody would do anything.

So I consider it normal when multi-ethnic states forcefully created and held together by a dictator (like Tito) where some ethnic group feels dominant and is preferred (by state jobs, political influence, whatever) and other are suppressed falls apart sooner or later.

Isfet Benovic

pre 8 godina

@Ari Gold.

You are well aware that Milan Nedic just like Pavelic were puppets of Germany. Both Serbs and Croats committed horrendous crimes. Please don't be so blind to the facts and say that Serbs played no part in the deportation of Jews and Roma. You call the massacre of 8,000 boys and men humane. Don't pretend to be righteous when your not. By the way the first resistance in YU during the Second World War were the Croats in Sisak. History will not be re written to destroy the lies. Give it up Ari, it's over !

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

If Albania was a NAZI supporter can you explain to me why Albania is part of "ALLIES COUNTRIES" against NAZI in the same time ???

- Because Albanians fought against Nazi.
- Because Albanians try to save all the Jews, and prisoners of other nationalities send to Albania. ( probably even Serbs )
(Joni, 7 May 2015 16:27)

Albania itself wasn't really involved in WWII. Germany never had a hard on for controlling Albania. It was Serbia's collective responsibility to be the primary opposition to Nazi occupation in the Balkans.

As far as the Jews finding safe haven in Albania, you are right. Because Nazi Germany never occupied or fought with Albania, many Jews were given asylum. That is commendable. But the Albanians in Kosovo-Metohija did form their own SS unit (Skenderbeg) and were some of the most loyal Nazi puppets. In return, they were allowed to control Kosovo-Metohija, and move in tons of their relatives from Albania.

icj1

pre 8 godina

China also invited Serbia for WWII commemorations later this year. It's great that Serbia is recognized as a desired partner for remembering this period in history. It's only right
(Ari Gold, 6 May 2015 19:54)

Yep and that just goes to demonstrate how easy is to buy naive Serbs with some symbolic gestures. When it comes to the real stuff like http://www.b92.net/eng/news/business.php?yyyy=2015&mm=05&dd=05&nav_id=94005 romanticism is quickly set aside, except for Serbia that continues with naive thinking. If Serbia had another NIS it would have probably sold it for a fistful of RMB just to be able to get the invitation to the parade lol

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

It's immensely important for Serbia to accept invitations from whoever is commemorating WWII. Serbs had to sacrifice a lot of civilian lives to stop fascism. We're talking 20 plus Croatian Nazi death camps and then all the sht that Germany itself did http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Retribution_%281941%29
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kragujevac_massacre...

China also invited Serbia for WWII commemorations later this year. It's great that Serbia is recognized as a desired partner for remembering this period in history. It's only right

Dwight

pre 8 godina

Ex high ranking CIA official just release a new book that clearly states the whole breakup of Yugoslavia and the wars that broke out was entirely planned and engineered by the CIA
(Pravda, 6 May 2015 16:31)

Other ex-CIA agents will tell you other versions but I don't see you quoting them.
Yugoslavia fell apart because of money, plain and simple.
Yugoslavia lived on cheap loans from both USSR and Europe and America which Tito played off each other masterfully.
When the USSR came apart the money dried up and no one was willing to make cutbacks.
Its always easier to blame someone else so the country came apart. In some ways Serbia was not to blame. As the home of Belgrade, that is where the money was dished out from. Like a gold-digger girlfriend, why would Croatia want to stay in a union with Serbia when its wallet was empty and the EU was throwing money around.
But hey, blame "the West" if it makes you feel better

Peggy

pre 8 godina

Like a gold-digger girlfriend, why would Croatia want to stay in a union with Serbia when its wallet was empty and the EU was throwing money around.
But hey, blame "the West" if it makes you feel better
(Dwight, 6 May 2015 21:16)
============================
So it has nothing to do with nationalism being free to rise to the level of hatred after Tito died?
If it was only money as you put it then why did Croatia bring out her old Nazi symbols and salutes? Yes, those poor innocent Crotians being robbed blind by Belgrade just had to revivie the old Nazi Independent Croatia.
Do any of the former republics live any better now? I don't think so.

Peggy

pre 8 godina

Always funny to see that people think those state break ups can be 'orchestrated', against the will of the people living there. Sure, it can be sparked, and encouraged, but when the people are satisfied with their situation, nobody would do anything.
=========================
Without political support and finance there would be no means to do it whether people wanted to or not. Give people plenty of propaganda, false hope and encouragement many will choose to go thinking that the grass is greener on the other side of the fence.
So yes, it was a plan by the west to do this and using the past spats it was very easy to incite people to do it all over again.
The west does have a lot of blood on their hands not just in the Balkans but all over the world.

Ari Gold

pre 8 godina

Just like they were the first balkan country to declare 'Juden Frei' in 1941. You don't deserve to march !
(Isfet Benovic, 7 May 2015 02:45)

Serbia wasn't a country during WWII. It was carved up by Germany and Belgrade + Central Serbia was directly occupied by the German military. There they committed huge atrocities against Jews and Serbs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kragujevac_massacre

Nice try, but Serbia is the only nation in Europe that had not one, but two anti-fascist movements. Serbia belongs at every Victory Day commemoration, and partners around the world are seeing that. You know who doesn't deserve to be there? The nations that produced SS Handzar, SS Skenderbeg and the "Independent" State of Croatia.

Gianfrancco

pre 8 godina

Bosniaks, croats and albanians should shut up here. They have always been friendly and allied with Nazi-Germany and Fascist-Italy.
The evil of Balkans, the evil of Europe.
The built their histories on big lies, since they have not a history. And their history is just being puppets of Hitler or Mussolini. Today nothing changed, because we recently saw people as Tudjiman, Izetbegovic, Thaqi, Rama who belong to the same group of criminals who were operating during the dark decades preceding WWII or during war itself.
Serbia and Serbs are and have always been a bulwark against Nazi-Fascism and their today's recrudescences.

rote

pre 8 godina

I am sure that 2 nations in Europe do not have to prove anything about the Great Victory. Those are the Serbs/Montenegrins who suffered about 300 000 combat losses and the English (220 000).Formally the Americans lost 400 000 but mostly from the Japanese. Because the USA fought them for 40 months and only 10 months against the Europeans headed by Hitler. And of course the colonial in the Far East had nothing to do with WW2.I would say that the USA simply conducted 2 wars at the time. Japan was only a formal member of the Axis. They betrayed Hitler and their PM was even coming to Moscow in 1942. Thus Serbo/Montenegrin people has suffered second big combat losses after the USSR. So (like the Brits) they don't need to explain anything or take any excuse. And if I were to decide I would arrange a joint parade in Belgrade inviting brothers in arms from Russia, Montenegro, Britain and Greece. And I would definitely send marching troops and the veterans to Moscow and Minsk Parades. S/M people deserves it more than anyone on the continent because it was almost the only fighting people outside USSR and GB. With very few exceptions like Greece ,the 20 000 Albanians, some 130 000 of the Poles all the rest sucked severely the way they could. They sucked the Germans for 3-4 years and then they sucked the Soviets & Co. But Serbs should behave as solid as the winners behave. And what do we have now ? Toma to Moscow, Vucic to Langley, Dacic to Kiev …

BeliOraoSrbija

pre 8 godina

I see the usual boot licking dirty knee crowd is here trying to make Serbia guilty of everything and revise history according to the lies they have been spoon fed all their lives.

Must have all been up all night rocking the bowl and hitting the pipe, to come up with those historical fantasies they write here.

Croat's, Bosian islamites, albanians, are the open mouth axis henchmen,and will forever be just that, some things never change do they?

Mick

pre 8 godina

@comm parison,
Multi-Ethnic?
Same language same people.. is no multi ethnic, or if you consider a saxon/austrian and bavarian to be a different ethnicity then yes.
The only difference is in religion and not accepting each other.
To have a better living standard in the Ottoman empire you had to be a muslim, for Austro-Hungary you had to be Catholic. Meaning many people converted so did Serbs.
Catholics in Bosnia are of many different ethnic backgrounds (German/Hungarian/Polish/Serbian/Slovak/Czech) Same for Croatia, but most are Serbian. The region Slavonia/Vojvodina are not called Rascia(alterenative name for serbia) for nothing back in the Austrian empire. The language Serbo-croatian is pure Serbian, in the 19th C Croats took the language for themselves, their own dialect is a Slovenian dialect(kajkavian).
The people of Bih/croatia/serbia/mne are most Serbs with a different religion but because of different political things that happened in the last 100 years people created their own views and ethnicity and here we are today divided and weak..

rote

pre 8 godina

@rote

What does Russian schools teach about USSR part in the war from 1939-June 1941? (Dwight)

You will be surprised but they teach us the truth. This is why Russia is in a much better position over any event in the past and in the presence. We simply call spade a spade and that’s it. Once someone whom the Americans elected 4 times for presidency said that “you cannot deceive many people for a long period of time”. It’s just impossible. So we do not lie and we tell the truth even when it helps someone to go on demonizing us in everything. And it gives good results. Say every May Russians buy red flags and posters for their cars. This year most deficit are stickers with slogan ЗА РОДИНУ ! ЗА СТАЛИНА ! Those were words ( FOR MOTHERLAND ! FOR STALIN!) that our soldiers were dying with during their attacks. I too failed to find it so I took another sticker НА БЕРЛИН ! It was written on our tanks, howitzers ect. and it looks rather amusing on my German BMW-530 car. And of course I have st. George ribbon in the salon. Those are the results of what they teach us. Despite the mud and hatred the West is pouring on us we remain teflonized when it comes to our Great Victory. You may persuade anybody else that Stalin and Hitler were the same but not us.

continued

rote

pre 8 godina

Dwight


PS :

Today 49% of the French believe that it was the USA who has won the war and only 23% remember that it was us. Who knows that in 1945 our armed forces reached 12 000 000 ? Who knows that during the war we mobilized 34 000 000 to the army ? Who cares that 38 my relatives including my Grandpa were not back ? Who the hell cares that Warsaw Riot as well as the Overlord Operation were not aimed against Hitler but against the USSR ? Who cares that UK lost in WW2 only 10% of what they lost in WW1 ? Who cares that the USA supplied Hitler till late 1942 ? Who cares that the French let the Nazi enter all their colonies and sending 2 000 000 workers to Germany?

Now you try to corner me with a simpliest question about Molotov-R Pact and the Winter War of 1939. So I say that in the circumstances the Pact was very good while the war was very bad. As simple as that. The USA and the Brits backed by France and Poland made their best to send Hitler to Russia so the Pact was a diplomatic victory of the USSR that helped us gain another year before the war. Russia is one of the few states who gained no territories in accordance with the Pact. Ask Ukrainians, Poles , Romanians and the Baltic Fascists. As for Finland it was punished for joining Hitler but during WW2 they behaved good and so Stalin forgave them in a great degree. We have nothing to be ashamed for in the period you mention. If you know something please tell it to us.

the end.

Comm. Parrisson

pre 8 godina

"Bosniaks, croats and albanians should shut up here. They have always been friendly and allied with Nazi-Germany and Fascist-Italy.
The evil of Balkans, the evil of Europe. ...
Serbia and Serbs are and have always been a bulwark against Nazi-Fascism and their today's recrudescences."
(Gianfrancco, 7 May 2015 13:10)

And today, they are friendly and allied with Russia under Putin, a state that celebrates Stalinism and where the people see Stalin as one of the most important Russians - which is not much better than fascism and Hitler.

Remember, a similar amount (some millions) of people in the Soviet union were killed in WW2 and perished because of Stalin's mass deportations, killings, ethnic cleansing and the famine inflicted by his politics.

Joni

pre 8 godina

(Gianfrancco, 7 May 2015 13:10)
Hmm, someone like "Gianfranco" tell to somebody to shut up. Mama mia Italiano ee??
1. Wars are not made with hands. If you are not militarily prepared and if you don't have any weapons to fight, you have no chance to resist, like it happened with Albanians.

2.I want to remember you that Serbs fought for "their existence", because Hitler decided to exterminate them. And since 1939 the Union Soviet begin to prepare militarily the Serbian resistance.

3. Hitler try to do with Albanians, the same thing that he did with Croatian, but he "failed" in his intention.
You understand?? Germany the most powerful superpower in the world at time, offered to Albanians the possibility to kick out Serbs and Greeks with their help. And Albanians decided to not accept it because we are not Serbs and Greeks we are a 'Great Albanian People".
I ask you what Serbs will have done if Germans offered to them the same thing???
Yes, i know for sure what they will do... Serbs and Turks are the same thing, they have "barbarian" instincts, they will kill all the Albanians with pleasure.

Ari Gold
Yes, there was a SS.Skanderbeg from may - november, just 6 months. And to much Albanians deserted for this it was not effective and disintegrated.
According to German sources ( not Albanian or Serbs - free to check ).
So, PLEASE, don't give to me LESSONS because we both know that if Hitler at time will give to you that "chance" you will burn us alive - with PLEASURE!!

Teodor Muzaka 1389

pre 8 godina

Albania was a Nazi supporter?
Serb commentators here are really funny.
If Albania was a Nazi supporter, how come that they were invited to attend in parade by Putin?
We got the same invitation as Serbia.
The difference is that we said NO THANK YOU Mr Putin and that's why we are not attending the celebrations.

Mick

pre 8 godina

@LK Yes a defenisive war, it was Serbs of Croatia that fought for their own right, it was Serbs from Bosnia that fought for their own rights and both did not want to be part of a Croat and Bosnian state but be a part of a Yugoslav state or Serbian state. The Serbs of Serbia did not participate after 1991.. If the remaining Yugoslav forces did participate in the war they would prevent the break up of Yugoslavia..

Joni

pre 8 godina

(BeliOraoSrbija, 7 May 2015 14:35)

If Albania was a NAZI supporter can you explain to me why Albania is part of "ALLIES COUNTRIES" against NAZI in the same time ???

- Because Albanians fought against Nazi.
- Because Albanians try to save all the Jews, and prisoners of other nationalities send to Albania. ( probably even Serbs )

Dwight

pre 8 godina

@Peggy
Nationalism was involved too for sure and it was stirred up by the leaders of Croatia and Serbia in particular.
I never said Serbs were robbing Croatia, what I said was Yugoslavia lived on cheap money. When the money dried up, central government told the regions to stop spending money, the regions told central government to shove it and started to make noises about splitting
( and here is the rise of nationalism from Croatia in particular). The leaders answer to this was to try and take away power and autonomy from the regions. This just made things worse. Basically each part of Yugoslavia knew there needed to be cutbacks but not for themselves

Are the individual countries better now than they were in Yugoslavia? No, but it is not always about that. Serbia would be better off if it had just let Kosovo split peacefully but it didnt allow that and for valid reasons which had nothing to do with finances

Would they be better off if Yugoslavia stayed together? maybe, if leaders back then had made some hard choices back then instead of looking for scapegoats

icj1

pre 8 godina

Today 49% of the French believe that it was the USA who has won the war and only 23% remember that it was us. Who knows that in 1945 our armed forces reached 12 000 000 ? Who knows that during the war we mobilized 34 000 000 to the army ? Who cares that 38 my relatives including my Grandpa were not back ?
(rote, 7 May 2015 16:55)

Well, it's hard to blame the French for that because the facts speak for themselves. The Soviet Union might have mobilized even 100 million to the army, if you wish, but the majority of the trucks that transported them to the front were provided by the US because the Soviet Union didn't have the industrial capacity to produce that many trucks. Mobilization meant nothing if those mobilized could not be transported to the front!!!

You might spin it as you wish but ultimately it comes down to that famous saying "it's the economy, stupid"

Joni

pre 8 godina

(Ari Gold, 7 May 2015 19:54)
What is for you an involvement? Please?
Being occupied from an Axis member for you in not involvement?
I can't deny the Serbs war against Nazi, as much as you can not deny that since the 1939 you was supported from Union Soviet military and they armed yours partisans.
I can't deny that Hitler hate you..
He don't hate us.. He was friendly to us, so why we should fight them please? But, we CHOOSE to fight them..
I think Albania military should accepted to go to Russia, but the politics are always like this, no?
Are you kidding me?
Don't tell to me that Albania was not occupied from Germans. Germans occupied Albania and killed all the Italians they found.
Albania is in a strategic position and Germans needed our ports. To many Albanian have died for it...
Found me another country in Europe ( except. Russia ) that "broke" the Hitler order.
We was at time just around 2 millions people, to easy to exterminate for Hitler who killed around 15 million or more people in Eu.