25

Friday, 26.10.2007.

11:39

Macedonia court bans display of Albanian flag

Macedonia’s Constitutional Court has decided to ban the use of the Albanian flag in certain locations.

Izvor: BIRN

Macedonia court bans display of Albanian flag IMAGE SOURCE
IMAGE DESCRIPTION

25 Komentari

Sortiraj po:

RAY

pre 16 godina

Once the ohrid agreement was forced on the Macedonians they lost control of 40% of thier state, there is little they can but watch greater Albania appear on thiee doorstep.

Unknown Comic

pre 16 godina

Well keep up the rhectoric folks remember it won't be another conflict like it was before. Macedonia was on it's on and now it is support by NATO. And the Support from albania won't be there for the fighters this time because they want to get into NATO and EU so they don't want to show there ARSE in the conflict so they will have a bunch a people running to Kosovo. Like before.

GSP

pre 16 godina

to doni -

Correct your comment, please -
KosovO does have a flag, but it is a Serbian flag. KosovO is Serbian land - it is NOT albanian.

Endri

pre 16 godina

The Macedonian court has no obligation to fly the Albanian flag
(Peter Sudyka, 26. October 2007 19:12)



Ohrid Agreement...

7.1. With respect to emblems, next to the emblem of the Republic of Macedonia, local authorities will be free to place on front of local public buildings emblems marking the identity of the
community in the majority in the municipality, respecting international rules and usages.

doni

pre 16 godina

Macedonia has to accept the albanian symbols, everywhere there are ethnic albanians. simple as that.

otherwise we need a new agreement on what the country's symbols should be.

because only a part of population (non-albanians)decided that flag. that's not democratic. albanians are not rapresented in it.
or let both flags. the albanian flag has nothing to do with albania, is just our identity.

Srboslav

pre 16 godina

Jeju, according to the albanians here and in the balkans (outside albania) its all part of greater Albania. Soutern Serbia, Makedonia, Montenegro, everywere there is a albanian person there is greater albania....

doni

pre 16 godina

kosovo has a flag, and thats the albanian flag, because all albanians have a flag, a language, an alphabet. They cannot invent other, because they cannot change history and who they are.

Peter Sudyka

pre 16 godina

What is it with this nationalism in the Balkans?

The Macedonian court has no obligation to fly the Albanian flag, nor does Macedonia have the obligation to change their name and flag because some Greeks get offended.

This region genuinely has a long way to go in terms of having a European mentality.

At least a modern one, not a pre-WW2 one like is seen here.

nikshala

pre 16 godina

The Ohrid agreement specifically allows albanian flag on govermental buidlings where albanians are majority.

So this is NOT respectiong the very agreement that stop the bloodshed.

This is such a stupid move. Somebody mention the policeman that got shot the other day. Do you think this decision will improve anyting? On the contrary, that criminal gang just got some new recruits!

The best example that proves that this is a wrong move, is what happened in Kosovo in the 90s. The hardline tactics of Belgrade, caused the loss of Kosovo.

So unless Macedonians want to lose a part of their coutnry, than they should rethink their policies.

By the way: i am not suprised at all by the support for this oppresive decision from some serb posters!

Philip Davies

pre 16 godina

Again people are misunderstanding the news article. The court decided that the Albanian flag cannot be flown on public buildings except on certain holidays. It doesn't stop private citizens flying the flag where ever else they want to. You cannot expect a government of a country to allow a flag other than their own to be flown from their own buildings.

Albanians don't make up 40% of the population - the census only revealed 25%.

Also I don't think Serbia ever banned flying the Albanian flag in Kosovo. Kosovo itself has never had its own flag. Vojvodina does now though.

smile

pre 16 godina

mr. teni - what turn for the better are you talking about? they just killed two officers there! Couple of months ago, another one. do you understand the gravity of killing a cop? you're shooting at the state when you shoot at the man with the badge. You're declaring war as you did in kosovo in 97, 98. and that is not good, that is not better.
As for the flag i'm sure there's a law in macedonia to tell everyone what they can and cant do. Just go with that hint. Its a non issue.
mr. nikshala – dont be bloody minded and show some respect for macedonia. they should not change their flag to accomodate you. you should accomodate macedonia as macedonian citizens and obey its laws.

doni

pre 16 godina

if macedonia change their flag is in Greece favor, because they will say that they are not macedonians but fyrom because of the changed flag

GSP

pre 16 godina

The bottom line is Serbia is Serbia; Makedonija is Makedonija & albania is albania. The only place where the flag of another country is permitted to fly (in conjunction with the flag of THAT country) is at an embassy. The building referenced in the article is a Makedonian government building in Makedonija - enough said.

The persons here provoking a very calm situation are the albanians.

albert

pre 16 godina

I think what the courts are doing is illegal and stirring up ethnic tension between the over 40 percent albanian minority and the so called macedonian wich is really below 20 percent . The true macedonian live in greece.

nikshala

pre 16 godina

Macedonia has a choice - it can follow the politics of Serbia in Kosovo, i.e. ban the flag an the rest..., (look where it got Serbia though) or be pragmatic, realistic, and make albanians (whose percentge is closer to 30-40%) feel like equal citizens.

Why shound albanian identity be reflected on the national symbols? we are not talking about 2% or 3% of popuation but close to half of population!!

If they do not want Macedonias albanians flying the albanian flag than they should change their current flag to reflect the mutli-ethnic make up of Macedonia!

teni

pre 16 godina

A very stupid decision on the part of the Macedonian Court just at a time when relations between the two communities were taking a turn for the better. What is it with the Balkans? Whenever things start to improve somebody always does something stupid and we end up worse then when we started.
The Macedonians need to understand that that is the flag of the Albanian people and not just of the Republic of Albania. Flying that flag therefore is not a sign of allegiance to the Republic of Albania, but an expression of Albanian identity. So what will the Macedonians do next? Eliminate Albanian as an official language?

jeju

pre 16 godina

I really don't understand how the flag of another national can be flown infront of another countries public offices. Is this Macedonia or Albania?

John

pre 16 godina

Albanian flags should not have been flying in Macedonia or Serbia in the first place. It contributes to disunity and it promoted nationalists. When is enough, pro-Albanians? This is how everything started in Serbia too, Albanians wanted so many rights which no minority in the world had and ultimately they did not fit within Serbian society so now they want independence. Lets see a Serb place a Serbian flag on a government building in Albania, I guarantee that flag would be burned.

AC

pre 16 godina

?How would they like it if ethnic minorities in Albania proper flew the flags of their respective foreign "mother countries" in municipalities where they constitute a majority?"

They already do. In sourthern Albania where there are some Greek minorities (which are much much much smaller than the Albanian minority in Macedonia), you can see Greek flags.

nikshala

pre 16 godina

What a thoughtful move and great timing by Macedonian authorities - NOT!!!! That is just asking for trouble.

A flag is just a symbol, and if it keeps 25 % of population happy than it it should not be a big deal if is allowed on few goverment buildings.

This is the Macedonian authorities backtracking from the Ohrid agreement.

I hope albanian community in Macedonia protest against this decision.

Albanians in Macedonia should be allowed to have their national albanian flag, the same way the K.serbs and K.a albanians will be allowed to wave their national flag next to the multiethnic flag of independent Kosovo.

GSP

pre 16 godina

The law on the use of flags was adopted in 2005, as part of the follow-up to the Ohrid peace deal that ended a six-month armed conflict between Albanian guerrillas and Macedonian security forces in 2001.

What does this tell you about the invaders? They will do ANYTHING to get what they want.

Pretty soon the UNMIK will be in Makedonija & then other Baltic states - the writing is on the wall.

Hopefully, this will be a wake up call for every super power that states KosovO should be independent.

doni

pre 16 godina

macedonians are just crazy.
they have scanderbeg statue in center of skopje, and many other albanian symbols. now they dicide to ban the flag.

Al

pre 16 godina

Why must they officially (!) fly another state's flag on Macedonian territory in the first place?
How would these Albanian nationalists like it if Serbs in northern Kosovo continued to publicly use Serbian national symbols there following the province's independence?
How would they like it if ethnic minorities in Albania proper flew the flags of their respective foreign "mother countries" in municipalities where they constitute a majority?
In my opinion, the Macedonian court ruling is more than fair in that it still allows Albanians to fly that foreign flag on their national holidays.

jeju

pre 16 godina

I really don't understand how the flag of another national can be flown infront of another countries public offices. Is this Macedonia or Albania?

John

pre 16 godina

Albanian flags should not have been flying in Macedonia or Serbia in the first place. It contributes to disunity and it promoted nationalists. When is enough, pro-Albanians? This is how everything started in Serbia too, Albanians wanted so many rights which no minority in the world had and ultimately they did not fit within Serbian society so now they want independence. Lets see a Serb place a Serbian flag on a government building in Albania, I guarantee that flag would be burned.

smile

pre 16 godina

mr. teni - what turn for the better are you talking about? they just killed two officers there! Couple of months ago, another one. do you understand the gravity of killing a cop? you're shooting at the state when you shoot at the man with the badge. You're declaring war as you did in kosovo in 97, 98. and that is not good, that is not better.
As for the flag i'm sure there's a law in macedonia to tell everyone what they can and cant do. Just go with that hint. Its a non issue.
mr. nikshala – dont be bloody minded and show some respect for macedonia. they should not change their flag to accomodate you. you should accomodate macedonia as macedonian citizens and obey its laws.

Philip Davies

pre 16 godina

Again people are misunderstanding the news article. The court decided that the Albanian flag cannot be flown on public buildings except on certain holidays. It doesn't stop private citizens flying the flag where ever else they want to. You cannot expect a government of a country to allow a flag other than their own to be flown from their own buildings.

Albanians don't make up 40% of the population - the census only revealed 25%.

Also I don't think Serbia ever banned flying the Albanian flag in Kosovo. Kosovo itself has never had its own flag. Vojvodina does now though.

Endri

pre 16 godina

The Macedonian court has no obligation to fly the Albanian flag
(Peter Sudyka, 26. October 2007 19:12)



Ohrid Agreement...

7.1. With respect to emblems, next to the emblem of the Republic of Macedonia, local authorities will be free to place on front of local public buildings emblems marking the identity of the
community in the majority in the municipality, respecting international rules and usages.

Al

pre 16 godina

Why must they officially (!) fly another state's flag on Macedonian territory in the first place?
How would these Albanian nationalists like it if Serbs in northern Kosovo continued to publicly use Serbian national symbols there following the province's independence?
How would they like it if ethnic minorities in Albania proper flew the flags of their respective foreign "mother countries" in municipalities where they constitute a majority?
In my opinion, the Macedonian court ruling is more than fair in that it still allows Albanians to fly that foreign flag on their national holidays.

GSP

pre 16 godina

The law on the use of flags was adopted in 2005, as part of the follow-up to the Ohrid peace deal that ended a six-month armed conflict between Albanian guerrillas and Macedonian security forces in 2001.

What does this tell you about the invaders? They will do ANYTHING to get what they want.

Pretty soon the UNMIK will be in Makedonija & then other Baltic states - the writing is on the wall.

Hopefully, this will be a wake up call for every super power that states KosovO should be independent.

GSP

pre 16 godina

The bottom line is Serbia is Serbia; Makedonija is Makedonija & albania is albania. The only place where the flag of another country is permitted to fly (in conjunction with the flag of THAT country) is at an embassy. The building referenced in the article is a Makedonian government building in Makedonija - enough said.

The persons here provoking a very calm situation are the albanians.

nikshala

pre 16 godina

What a thoughtful move and great timing by Macedonian authorities - NOT!!!! That is just asking for trouble.

A flag is just a symbol, and if it keeps 25 % of population happy than it it should not be a big deal if is allowed on few goverment buildings.

This is the Macedonian authorities backtracking from the Ohrid agreement.

I hope albanian community in Macedonia protest against this decision.

Albanians in Macedonia should be allowed to have their national albanian flag, the same way the K.serbs and K.a albanians will be allowed to wave their national flag next to the multiethnic flag of independent Kosovo.

doni

pre 16 godina

macedonians are just crazy.
they have scanderbeg statue in center of skopje, and many other albanian symbols. now they dicide to ban the flag.

doni

pre 16 godina

kosovo has a flag, and thats the albanian flag, because all albanians have a flag, a language, an alphabet. They cannot invent other, because they cannot change history and who they are.

doni

pre 16 godina

Macedonia has to accept the albanian symbols, everywhere there are ethnic albanians. simple as that.

otherwise we need a new agreement on what the country's symbols should be.

because only a part of population (non-albanians)decided that flag. that's not democratic. albanians are not rapresented in it.
or let both flags. the albanian flag has nothing to do with albania, is just our identity.

AC

pre 16 godina

?How would they like it if ethnic minorities in Albania proper flew the flags of their respective foreign "mother countries" in municipalities where they constitute a majority?"

They already do. In sourthern Albania where there are some Greek minorities (which are much much much smaller than the Albanian minority in Macedonia), you can see Greek flags.

albert

pre 16 godina

I think what the courts are doing is illegal and stirring up ethnic tension between the over 40 percent albanian minority and the so called macedonian wich is really below 20 percent . The true macedonian live in greece.

teni

pre 16 godina

A very stupid decision on the part of the Macedonian Court just at a time when relations between the two communities were taking a turn for the better. What is it with the Balkans? Whenever things start to improve somebody always does something stupid and we end up worse then when we started.
The Macedonians need to understand that that is the flag of the Albanian people and not just of the Republic of Albania. Flying that flag therefore is not a sign of allegiance to the Republic of Albania, but an expression of Albanian identity. So what will the Macedonians do next? Eliminate Albanian as an official language?

nikshala

pre 16 godina

Macedonia has a choice - it can follow the politics of Serbia in Kosovo, i.e. ban the flag an the rest..., (look where it got Serbia though) or be pragmatic, realistic, and make albanians (whose percentge is closer to 30-40%) feel like equal citizens.

Why shound albanian identity be reflected on the national symbols? we are not talking about 2% or 3% of popuation but close to half of population!!

If they do not want Macedonias albanians flying the albanian flag than they should change their current flag to reflect the mutli-ethnic make up of Macedonia!

Peter Sudyka

pre 16 godina

What is it with this nationalism in the Balkans?

The Macedonian court has no obligation to fly the Albanian flag, nor does Macedonia have the obligation to change their name and flag because some Greeks get offended.

This region genuinely has a long way to go in terms of having a European mentality.

At least a modern one, not a pre-WW2 one like is seen here.

Srboslav

pre 16 godina

Jeju, according to the albanians here and in the balkans (outside albania) its all part of greater Albania. Soutern Serbia, Makedonia, Montenegro, everywere there is a albanian person there is greater albania....

nikshala

pre 16 godina

The Ohrid agreement specifically allows albanian flag on govermental buidlings where albanians are majority.

So this is NOT respectiong the very agreement that stop the bloodshed.

This is such a stupid move. Somebody mention the policeman that got shot the other day. Do you think this decision will improve anyting? On the contrary, that criminal gang just got some new recruits!

The best example that proves that this is a wrong move, is what happened in Kosovo in the 90s. The hardline tactics of Belgrade, caused the loss of Kosovo.

So unless Macedonians want to lose a part of their coutnry, than they should rethink their policies.

By the way: i am not suprised at all by the support for this oppresive decision from some serb posters!

GSP

pre 16 godina

to doni -

Correct your comment, please -
KosovO does have a flag, but it is a Serbian flag. KosovO is Serbian land - it is NOT albanian.

doni

pre 16 godina

if macedonia change their flag is in Greece favor, because they will say that they are not macedonians but fyrom because of the changed flag

Unknown Comic

pre 16 godina

Well keep up the rhectoric folks remember it won't be another conflict like it was before. Macedonia was on it's on and now it is support by NATO. And the Support from albania won't be there for the fighters this time because they want to get into NATO and EU so they don't want to show there ARSE in the conflict so they will have a bunch a people running to Kosovo. Like before.

RAY

pre 16 godina

Once the ohrid agreement was forced on the Macedonians they lost control of 40% of thier state, there is little they can but watch greater Albania appear on thiee doorstep.

albert

pre 16 godina

I think what the courts are doing is illegal and stirring up ethnic tension between the over 40 percent albanian minority and the so called macedonian wich is really below 20 percent . The true macedonian live in greece.

teni

pre 16 godina

A very stupid decision on the part of the Macedonian Court just at a time when relations between the two communities were taking a turn for the better. What is it with the Balkans? Whenever things start to improve somebody always does something stupid and we end up worse then when we started.
The Macedonians need to understand that that is the flag of the Albanian people and not just of the Republic of Albania. Flying that flag therefore is not a sign of allegiance to the Republic of Albania, but an expression of Albanian identity. So what will the Macedonians do next? Eliminate Albanian as an official language?

nikshala

pre 16 godina

What a thoughtful move and great timing by Macedonian authorities - NOT!!!! That is just asking for trouble.

A flag is just a symbol, and if it keeps 25 % of population happy than it it should not be a big deal if is allowed on few goverment buildings.

This is the Macedonian authorities backtracking from the Ohrid agreement.

I hope albanian community in Macedonia protest against this decision.

Albanians in Macedonia should be allowed to have their national albanian flag, the same way the K.serbs and K.a albanians will be allowed to wave their national flag next to the multiethnic flag of independent Kosovo.

nikshala

pre 16 godina

Macedonia has a choice - it can follow the politics of Serbia in Kosovo, i.e. ban the flag an the rest..., (look where it got Serbia though) or be pragmatic, realistic, and make albanians (whose percentge is closer to 30-40%) feel like equal citizens.

Why shound albanian identity be reflected on the national symbols? we are not talking about 2% or 3% of popuation but close to half of population!!

If they do not want Macedonias albanians flying the albanian flag than they should change their current flag to reflect the mutli-ethnic make up of Macedonia!

doni

pre 16 godina

kosovo has a flag, and thats the albanian flag, because all albanians have a flag, a language, an alphabet. They cannot invent other, because they cannot change history and who they are.

GSP

pre 16 godina

The law on the use of flags was adopted in 2005, as part of the follow-up to the Ohrid peace deal that ended a six-month armed conflict between Albanian guerrillas and Macedonian security forces in 2001.

What does this tell you about the invaders? They will do ANYTHING to get what they want.

Pretty soon the UNMIK will be in Makedonija & then other Baltic states - the writing is on the wall.

Hopefully, this will be a wake up call for every super power that states KosovO should be independent.

doni

pre 16 godina

macedonians are just crazy.
they have scanderbeg statue in center of skopje, and many other albanian symbols. now they dicide to ban the flag.

jeju

pre 16 godina

I really don't understand how the flag of another national can be flown infront of another countries public offices. Is this Macedonia or Albania?

John

pre 16 godina

Albanian flags should not have been flying in Macedonia or Serbia in the first place. It contributes to disunity and it promoted nationalists. When is enough, pro-Albanians? This is how everything started in Serbia too, Albanians wanted so many rights which no minority in the world had and ultimately they did not fit within Serbian society so now they want independence. Lets see a Serb place a Serbian flag on a government building in Albania, I guarantee that flag would be burned.

AC

pre 16 godina

?How would they like it if ethnic minorities in Albania proper flew the flags of their respective foreign "mother countries" in municipalities where they constitute a majority?"

They already do. In sourthern Albania where there are some Greek minorities (which are much much much smaller than the Albanian minority in Macedonia), you can see Greek flags.

doni

pre 16 godina

if macedonia change their flag is in Greece favor, because they will say that they are not macedonians but fyrom because of the changed flag

smile

pre 16 godina

mr. teni - what turn for the better are you talking about? they just killed two officers there! Couple of months ago, another one. do you understand the gravity of killing a cop? you're shooting at the state when you shoot at the man with the badge. You're declaring war as you did in kosovo in 97, 98. and that is not good, that is not better.
As for the flag i'm sure there's a law in macedonia to tell everyone what they can and cant do. Just go with that hint. Its a non issue.
mr. nikshala – dont be bloody minded and show some respect for macedonia. they should not change their flag to accomodate you. you should accomodate macedonia as macedonian citizens and obey its laws.

Philip Davies

pre 16 godina

Again people are misunderstanding the news article. The court decided that the Albanian flag cannot be flown on public buildings except on certain holidays. It doesn't stop private citizens flying the flag where ever else they want to. You cannot expect a government of a country to allow a flag other than their own to be flown from their own buildings.

Albanians don't make up 40% of the population - the census only revealed 25%.

Also I don't think Serbia ever banned flying the Albanian flag in Kosovo. Kosovo itself has never had its own flag. Vojvodina does now though.

nikshala

pre 16 godina

The Ohrid agreement specifically allows albanian flag on govermental buidlings where albanians are majority.

So this is NOT respectiong the very agreement that stop the bloodshed.

This is such a stupid move. Somebody mention the policeman that got shot the other day. Do you think this decision will improve anyting? On the contrary, that criminal gang just got some new recruits!

The best example that proves that this is a wrong move, is what happened in Kosovo in the 90s. The hardline tactics of Belgrade, caused the loss of Kosovo.

So unless Macedonians want to lose a part of their coutnry, than they should rethink their policies.

By the way: i am not suprised at all by the support for this oppresive decision from some serb posters!

doni

pre 16 godina

Macedonia has to accept the albanian symbols, everywhere there are ethnic albanians. simple as that.

otherwise we need a new agreement on what the country's symbols should be.

because only a part of population (non-albanians)decided that flag. that's not democratic. albanians are not rapresented in it.
or let both flags. the albanian flag has nothing to do with albania, is just our identity.

Srboslav

pre 16 godina

Jeju, according to the albanians here and in the balkans (outside albania) its all part of greater Albania. Soutern Serbia, Makedonia, Montenegro, everywere there is a albanian person there is greater albania....

Endri

pre 16 godina

The Macedonian court has no obligation to fly the Albanian flag
(Peter Sudyka, 26. October 2007 19:12)



Ohrid Agreement...

7.1. With respect to emblems, next to the emblem of the Republic of Macedonia, local authorities will be free to place on front of local public buildings emblems marking the identity of the
community in the majority in the municipality, respecting international rules and usages.

GSP

pre 16 godina

to doni -

Correct your comment, please -
KosovO does have a flag, but it is a Serbian flag. KosovO is Serbian land - it is NOT albanian.

Al

pre 16 godina

Why must they officially (!) fly another state's flag on Macedonian territory in the first place?
How would these Albanian nationalists like it if Serbs in northern Kosovo continued to publicly use Serbian national symbols there following the province's independence?
How would they like it if ethnic minorities in Albania proper flew the flags of their respective foreign "mother countries" in municipalities where they constitute a majority?
In my opinion, the Macedonian court ruling is more than fair in that it still allows Albanians to fly that foreign flag on their national holidays.

GSP

pre 16 godina

The bottom line is Serbia is Serbia; Makedonija is Makedonija & albania is albania. The only place where the flag of another country is permitted to fly (in conjunction with the flag of THAT country) is at an embassy. The building referenced in the article is a Makedonian government building in Makedonija - enough said.

The persons here provoking a very calm situation are the albanians.

Peter Sudyka

pre 16 godina

What is it with this nationalism in the Balkans?

The Macedonian court has no obligation to fly the Albanian flag, nor does Macedonia have the obligation to change their name and flag because some Greeks get offended.

This region genuinely has a long way to go in terms of having a European mentality.

At least a modern one, not a pre-WW2 one like is seen here.

Unknown Comic

pre 16 godina

Well keep up the rhectoric folks remember it won't be another conflict like it was before. Macedonia was on it's on and now it is support by NATO. And the Support from albania won't be there for the fighters this time because they want to get into NATO and EU so they don't want to show there ARSE in the conflict so they will have a bunch a people running to Kosovo. Like before.

RAY

pre 16 godina

Once the ohrid agreement was forced on the Macedonians they lost control of 40% of thier state, there is little they can but watch greater Albania appear on thiee doorstep.