Montenegrin is variant of Serbian language - US authority

Same applies to Croatian. Best solution would be to codify the language as serbo-croatian.

Montenegrins are Serbs only fooled by some politicians and fools...their populations is 400,000 in the world including Montenegro for a reason....I am Montenegrin but a Serb......just like everyone in former Yugoslavia besides Slovenia speaks Serbian.....croats just started changing some words to say its Croatia and those words sound stupid...

Duh, I am a Montenegrin Serb. In Montenegro, there are only Serbs, Bosniaks and Albanians...plus the small but powerful handful of self-hating UDBA MILOnegrins.

"Montenegrin" is not a variant of Serbian. The language does not exist, it is Serbian. Like someone saying they speak "American" instead of English.

This is all part of the campaign to keep the region divided.

Montenegrin is variant of Serbian language - US authority

The language is also known by its more popular names, Lazy Serbian and Gundja.

This must be as first......those Americans finally got something right!!!!!

This is impossible, every time I go to Podgorica to obtain documents I have to wait an extra few days to obtain them because I request the documents in Serbian. It must be extremely difficult for the government staff to translate Montenegrin to Serbian, but I wouldn't know because I can not communicate with them, I only speak Serbian and not Montenegrin.

Montenegrin is NOT Serbian. An example of a dialect would be what Macedonian is to Bulgarian. But Montenegrin is not the same thing to Serbian, Montenegrin is its own language!
(Crno, 11 July 2017 18:52
=====================
Do tell us how. Do you need a translator when you go to Serbia?
How exactly is Montenegrin not the same language?

BTW, English speaking countries don't use their minor differences in language to make up new languages.
US has many differences from England but they still speak English not American. Same with Australia and New Zealand and Canada.
It's all English.
It's all Serbian.
Same with Bosnian. Since when is that a separate language?

Only in the Balkans where the hatred runs so deeply that 4 languages have been crated from 1 (Serbian). The difference between Serbian, Croatian, Bosniak and Montenegrin is similar to the difference between English speaking Americans from the north and English speaking Americans from the south. Yes, some words are different and phraseology may be different, but in no case is it enough to justify a new and distinct language. My family is from Montenegro and I have relatives in both Montenegro and Serbia and guess what? They all understand each other without a translator. Very silly stuff.

All Slavs spoke at least two languages before 17 century - Slovenski as the single official language of the Great (Roman, Mongol, Tartar) Horde and Turkic (not Turkish!) as the international language. So the differences among the Slavic languages appeared after they became submitted to the West.

If you have a good look at the Montenegrin flag you will find the coat of arms of the Great Horde where only two smaller crowns are missing. But in the center there's the emblem of the Great Princedome of Bulgar (Великое Княжество Булгарское) that explains everything. No nations or states have existed on the Balkans before 19 century ... NEVER !!!!!!!!!!

dear icj, you try ever so hard to zing, you miss things far too often.

explain the terms african american? dutch jew? french canadian.

in there you'll find the answers you're looking for

No nations or states have existed on the Balkans before 19 century ... NEVER !!!!!!!!!!
(rote, 11 July 2017 17:06) # Comment link

How did Kosova become so called "cradle of serbia"?

Macedonian and Bulgarian are surely further apart than Serbian and Montenegrin. Croatian, Bosnian, Montenegrin and Serbian are all dialects of the same language. The reasons for separating them are purely political, not linguistics. Even dialects inside Macedonia are further apart than Serbian and Montenegrin.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIYS9EQWkXg

Montenegrin is NOT Serbian. An example of a dialect would be what Macedonian is to Bulgarian. But Montenegrin is not the same thing to Serbian, Montenegrin is its own language!

Hey Rote, It's time to have your vodka examined again.

P.S. Don't let the debil drive your car.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAsv6j7cs4o

English is spoken in Great Britain, US,Australia, India ,Hong Kong etc.....

Independant countries do share similar languages .....so what?
Shqiperia and Kosova both speak Albanian.

Montenagrian language is as much a variant of Croatia language as its Serbian.

It's just as possible the Serbian language is really a variant of the Croatian or Montenegrin language!

I am a Montenegrin Serb. In Montenegro, there are only Serbs, Bosniaks and Albanians...plus the small but powerful handful of self-hating UDBA MILOnegrins.
(Ari Gold, 11 July 2017 15:52)

How can there only be "Serbs, Bosniaks and Albanians" in Montengro when you just said that you are a "Montenegrin Serb"?!!! Dear, you're really amazing in managing to contradict yourself in just two sentences lol

It's just as possible the Serbian language is really a variant of the Croatian or Montenegrin language!
(Azir, 12 July 2017 02:55)
=================
No it's not. Serbian being the language of the largest demographic had a lot of influence in the way Croats spoke.
After the war of the 90s Croats decided to change all that and what we have now is anyone's guess.

I am Croatian and neither Croatian, nor Montenegrin is Serbian. They are their own languages with NOTHING to do with Serbia. Just because Serbs copy many of our words, does NOT mean the languages are the same.
(Hrvatska, 12 July 2017 22:20)
=======================
Now I've heard it all.
Serbs would have to copy the entire language not just a few words. Do you need an interpreter when you speak to a Serb? Does a person from Montenegro need one? Geez, Montenegrins are studying in Serbian universities but they had to learn the language first?
We are all same people only separated by religion. We are all Slavs and our language is the same with some variations. Two villages in the same area might have some variations, let alone people spread over such a large area.
If you had any intelligence you would have common sense to see this.
How is Cyrillic used in Croatia a copy of Croatian? You don't see that it was primarily Serbian in that region warped to sound like something else.

I'm curious now!
If a serbian colony goes to settle in Mars can they pretend they will speak marsian language!?

The respected authority has spoken! Why would you debate something that will not change? Its a variant of the Serb language.

I guess the only positive point I can make is on my Curriculum Vitae (CV) I put down that I speak all languages: Serbian, Bosnian, Croatian & Montenegrin - makes me look super multi lingual!

You don't see that it was primarily Serbian in that region warped to sound like something else.
(Peggy, 14 July 2017 02:31)

Well, from Croatia's point of view, the language spoken is Serbia is primarily Croatian warped to sound like something else.

Obviously both Croatia and Serbia's point of view are correct from the perspective of each of them.

njegos

IN FACT ALL SLAVIC LANGUAGES WERE SLOVENSKI IN 16 CENTURY. IT WAS THE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE. SURE THERE COULD BE REGIONAL DIALECTS OF THE LANGUAGE BUT THE DIFFERENCE COULD NOT BE BIG ENOUGH TO FORM SEPARATE LANGUAGES. FORMALLY BEFORE 16 CENTURY ALL BALKAN PEOPLES INCLUDING THE ROMANIANS, MOLDOVANS AND SHQIPTARS WERE BULGARS I.E. VOLGA PEOPLE OF THE ВЕЛИКОЕ КНЯЖЕСТВО БУЛГАРСКОЕ REFLECTED ON THE GREAT STAMP OF IVAN GROZNY.

https://secrethistory.su/428-o-chem-govorit-bolshaya-gosudarstvennaya-pechat-ivana-groznogo.html

Albert,

Bulgarian and Macedonian are 95% identical. After all, Macedonian is a Western Bulgarian dialect.

I am Croatian and neither Croatian, nor Montenegrin is Serbian. They are their own languages with NOTHING to do with Serbia. Just because Serbs copy many of our words, does NOT mean the languages are the same.

Serbian language originates from Ukraine/Russian mountain caves.

After invasion of thousands he Balkans and After learning to walk on two Serbs copied Croatian and Montenegrins 🇲🇪 language.

The reason Serbs are 6 million is because they multiply like rabbits .

Montenegrin is NOT Serbian. An example of a dialect would be what Macedonian is to Bulgarian. But Montenegrin is not the same thing to Serbian, Montenegrin is its own language!

English is spoken in Great Britain, US,Australia, India ,Hong Kong etc.....

Independant countries do share similar languages .....so what?
Shqiperia and Kosova both speak Albanian.

Montenagrian language is as much a variant of Croatia language as its Serbian.

It's just as possible the Serbian language is really a variant of the Croatian or Montenegrin language!

I am a Montenegrin Serb. In Montenegro, there are only Serbs, Bosniaks and Albanians...plus the small but powerful handful of self-hating UDBA MILOnegrins.
(Ari Gold, 11 July 2017 15:52)

How can there only be "Serbs, Bosniaks and Albanians" in Montengro when you just said that you are a "Montenegrin Serb"?!!! Dear, you're really amazing in managing to contradict yourself in just two sentences lol

No nations or states have existed on the Balkans before 19 century ... NEVER !!!!!!!!!!
(rote, 11 July 2017 17:06) # Comment link

How did Kosova become so called "cradle of serbia"?

All Slavs spoke at least two languages before 17 century - Slovenski as the single official language of the Great (Roman, Mongol, Tartar) Horde and Turkic (not Turkish!) as the international language. So the differences among the Slavic languages appeared after they became submitted to the West.

If you have a good look at the Montenegrin flag you will find the coat of arms of the Great Horde where only two smaller crowns are missing. But in the center there's the emblem of the Great Princedome of Bulgar (Великое Княжество Булгарское) that explains everything. No nations or states have existed on the Balkans before 19 century ... NEVER !!!!!!!!!!

Albert,

Bulgarian and Macedonian are 95% identical. After all, Macedonian is a Western Bulgarian dialect.

I am Croatian and neither Croatian, nor Montenegrin is Serbian. They are their own languages with NOTHING to do with Serbia. Just because Serbs copy many of our words, does NOT mean the languages are the same.

Duh, I am a Montenegrin Serb. In Montenegro, there are only Serbs, Bosniaks and Albanians...plus the small but powerful handful of self-hating UDBA MILOnegrins.

Same applies to Croatian. Best solution would be to codify the language as serbo-croatian.

Montenegrins are Serbs only fooled by some politicians and fools...their populations is 400,000 in the world including Montenegro for a reason....I am Montenegrin but a Serb......just like everyone in former Yugoslavia besides Slovenia speaks Serbian.....croats just started changing some words to say its Croatia and those words sound stupid...

Only in the Balkans where the hatred runs so deeply that 4 languages have been crated from 1 (Serbian). The difference between Serbian, Croatian, Bosniak and Montenegrin is similar to the difference between English speaking Americans from the north and English speaking Americans from the south. Yes, some words are different and phraseology may be different, but in no case is it enough to justify a new and distinct language. My family is from Montenegro and I have relatives in both Montenegro and Serbia and guess what? They all understand each other without a translator. Very silly stuff.

Serbian language originates from Ukraine/Russian mountain caves.

After invasion of thousands he Balkans and After learning to walk on two Serbs copied Croatian and Montenegrins 🇲🇪 language.

The reason Serbs are 6 million is because they multiply like rabbits .

Hey Rote, It's time to have your vodka examined again.

P.S. Don't let the debil drive your car.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAsv6j7cs4o

Montenegrin is NOT Serbian. An example of a dialect would be what Macedonian is to Bulgarian. But Montenegrin is not the same thing to Serbian, Montenegrin is its own language!
(Crno, 11 July 2017 18:52
=====================
Do tell us how. Do you need a translator when you go to Serbia?
How exactly is Montenegrin not the same language?

BTW, English speaking countries don't use their minor differences in language to make up new languages.
US has many differences from England but they still speak English not American. Same with Australia and New Zealand and Canada.
It's all English.
It's all Serbian.
Same with Bosnian. Since when is that a separate language?

I'm curious now!
If a serbian colony goes to settle in Mars can they pretend they will speak marsian language!?

It's just as possible the Serbian language is really a variant of the Croatian or Montenegrin language!
(Azir, 12 July 2017 02:55)
=================
No it's not. Serbian being the language of the largest demographic had a lot of influence in the way Croats spoke.
After the war of the 90s Croats decided to change all that and what we have now is anyone's guess.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIYS9EQWkXg

This must be as first......those Americans finally got something right!!!!!

This is impossible, every time I go to Podgorica to obtain documents I have to wait an extra few days to obtain them because I request the documents in Serbian. It must be extremely difficult for the government staff to translate Montenegrin to Serbian, but I wouldn't know because I can not communicate with them, I only speak Serbian and not Montenegrin.

"Montenegrin" is not a variant of Serbian. The language does not exist, it is Serbian. Like someone saying they speak "American" instead of English.

This is all part of the campaign to keep the region divided.

Montenegrin is variant of Serbian language - US authority

The language is also known by its more popular names, Lazy Serbian and Gundja.

I am Croatian and neither Croatian, nor Montenegrin is Serbian. They are their own languages with NOTHING to do with Serbia. Just because Serbs copy many of our words, does NOT mean the languages are the same.
(Hrvatska, 12 July 2017 22:20)
=======================
Now I've heard it all.
Serbs would have to copy the entire language not just a few words. Do you need an interpreter when you speak to a Serb? Does a person from Montenegro need one? Geez, Montenegrins are studying in Serbian universities but they had to learn the language first?
We are all same people only separated by religion. We are all Slavs and our language is the same with some variations. Two villages in the same area might have some variations, let alone people spread over such a large area.
If you had any intelligence you would have common sense to see this.
How is Cyrillic used in Croatia a copy of Croatian? You don't see that it was primarily Serbian in that region warped to sound like something else.

njegos

IN FACT ALL SLAVIC LANGUAGES WERE SLOVENSKI IN 16 CENTURY. IT WAS THE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE. SURE THERE COULD BE REGIONAL DIALECTS OF THE LANGUAGE BUT THE DIFFERENCE COULD NOT BE BIG ENOUGH TO FORM SEPARATE LANGUAGES. FORMALLY BEFORE 16 CENTURY ALL BALKAN PEOPLES INCLUDING THE ROMANIANS, MOLDOVANS AND SHQIPTARS WERE BULGARS I.E. VOLGA PEOPLE OF THE ВЕЛИКОЕ КНЯЖЕСТВО БУЛГАРСКОЕ REFLECTED ON THE GREAT STAMP OF IVAN GROZNY.

https://secrethistory.su/428-o-chem-govorit-bolshaya-gosudarstvennaya-pechat-ivana-groznogo.html

dear icj, you try ever so hard to zing, you miss things far too often.

explain the terms african american? dutch jew? french canadian.

in there you'll find the answers you're looking for

Macedonian and Bulgarian are surely further apart than Serbian and Montenegrin. Croatian, Bosnian, Montenegrin and Serbian are all dialects of the same language. The reasons for separating them are purely political, not linguistics. Even dialects inside Macedonia are further apart than Serbian and Montenegrin.

The respected authority has spoken! Why would you debate something that will not change? Its a variant of the Serb language.

I guess the only positive point I can make is on my Curriculum Vitae (CV) I put down that I speak all languages: Serbian, Bosnian, Croatian & Montenegrin - makes me look super multi lingual!

You don't see that it was primarily Serbian in that region warped to sound like something else.
(Peggy, 14 July 2017 02:31)

Well, from Croatia's point of view, the language spoken is Serbia is primarily Croatian warped to sound like something else.

Obviously both Croatia and Serbia's point of view are correct from the perspective of each of them.